9 ms·
>Various government agencies are crooning that they should be able to knock down whichever doors they please because they're the government. I think this analo
by slg 11y ago
>Various government agencies are crooning that they should be able to knock down whichever doors they please because they're the government.
I think this analogy is apt but it actually works against the author's point. Our government has legally been allowed to knock down whichever door it has wanted to for centuries assuming it has received the proper warrants. An encryption door cannot be knocked down. That is a very scary problem for the government and law enforcement. Things like personal notes, journals, communications all used to be accessible to the government through warrants. Now that information is all locked away behind encryption. This is a huge shift in the way governments fight crime. We need to recognize that fact in order to have any productive debate with anti-encryption folks and we can't just pretend the government is evil because they wanted to keep the status quo of the physical world alive into the digital era.
- x5n1 11y agoNot true. You can jail the person for not revealing passwords if you have enough evidence and reasons to suspect the person is guilty and is hiding evidence behind encryption. This is not about being able to access something. This is about the ability to illegally search and seize all information at all times, often without any warrant at all. The government is worried not about not being able to search it, it's grasping for more totalitarian control of people's thoughts and behaviors. I guess because it's scared of what people are capable of.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> Things like personal notes, journals, communications all used to be accessible to the government through warrants. Now that information is all locked away behind encryption. The government already has plenty of ways to collect evidence through legal means. A judge can compel you to provide access to your company files, to unlock your home, to decrypt your computer, etc. If you don't comply with the discovery process, you can be held in contempt of court. Encryption doesn't change anything in that equation. The difference here is that the person in question is dead, so he can't provide the password. So the FBI wants to set a precedent that they can obtain information they want through means that would normally not be available to them.
- x5n1 11y agoPeople die all the time after committing nefarious crimes. In this case the police killed them. Maybe the police is to blame for the fact that we can not get to the truth about the crime. If there is any truth to be found, other than disillusioned religious people go on a murderous rampage all on their own. I mean justice, well in many cases there can't be justice. The long arm of the law can't reach everyone anywhere, especially after death.
- zardo 11y agoDead men take secrets to the grave every day. Brain communication interfaces aren't that far off though, so maybe we can solve this "problem" with the our minds being dark to the FBI in a decade or two.
- mc808 11y ago> Now that information is all locked away behind encryption. Moreover, more and more of that persistent information is casual communication that historically would have been securely erased by the whispering winds of time. No judge can grant investigators a time machine to travel back and spy on thousands of conversations over the last 5 years to fish for evidence. But now they can have the next-best thing (and getting better).
- pif 11y ago> But now they can have the next-best thing... I think the discussion will get more useful when we'll stop talking about them and instead will talk about us. In civilized countries, the government represents the people. Law-enforcing organisms are mandated by people. The question is not whether some stranger wants to be able to enforce the law: the problem is whether we want to be able to enforce the law.
- cmdrfred 11y agoIt has been empirically proven[1] that the United States is not a democracy. At least not in any meaningful way. [1] http://www.businessinsider.com/major-study-finds-that-the-us-is-an-oligarchy-2014-4 http://www.businessinsider.com/major-study-finds-that-the-us...
- jonwachob91 11y agoYou are 100% correct, the US is not a Democracy. IT'S A REPUBLIC. The same citizens complaining that the rich control our country are the same citizens who don't register to vote because their opinion doesn't matter. The person who screams the loudest is the person heard. And the voice of America takes a sad me me me view that their voice doesn't matter, thus the rich get the power. I'm far from a Sanders supporter, but his way of running this campaign has given America their Voice back. Ban super PACS, and limit corporate contributions to the same dollar amount that you and I are limited to donating, $2700.
- mc808 11y agoNaturally we want to be able to enforce the law. We should also remember the 20th century and how quickly "they" seized control of Germany, Italy, Japan, China, Korea, the Soviet republics, Iran, Iraq, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Libya, Brazil, Chile, Argentina, Nicaragua, Cuba, the list goes on. All of that without the benefit of universal surveillance and time scrying technology. In pursuit of enforcing the law, we need to be vigilant in maintaining the rule of law, which has proved difficult over the last century, with dire consequences.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y ago>Our government has legally been allowed to knock down whichever door it has wanted to for centuries assuming it has received the proper warrants. But it hasn't been able to trawl for evidence mechanically and automatically. Now it has the technology to do that. The default has always been privacy, for practical reasons. Encryption simply continues that tradition by continuing to make evidence gathering non-trivial.
- rtpg 11y agoThe mechanical and automatic nature of evidence gathering is a real difference, and goes well to argue against NSA-style warrantless crawling. I think for warrants, though, we're looking at a different beast. By their nature they are targeted. And people have been compelled to provide passwords in the court of law(See [0]). The right against self-incrimination is relatively narrow, so as to not hinder the government's discoverability powers too much. I think the one thing about this, though, is that people can already be compelled through legal means to unlock things. There is a reading of the Apple case that they are being compelled to unlock something for which they have the key. Generally, it feels like outlawing encryption isn't necessary for the gov't to pursue the discovery phase of an arrest. There are already a good amount of legal means to compel people to unlock the doors. [0]:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law#United_Stat...
- marklgr 11y ago> And people have been compelled to provide passwords in the court of law You can have encrypted data that accept two different passwords, producing different decrypted data of your choice. This is like the 2nd code that mute the home security alarm when you are forced to do it, but still calls the police.
- techdragon 11y agoDuress codes and embassy grade encryption are an interesting topic. Attempting to address the real world implications of "rubber hose cryptanalysis" is increasing important.
- Gustomaximus 11y agoI feel part of the problem is that people recognize what you say, and understand its helpful, even necessary for government to have warranted access. The big BUT however is many of us are losing trust in our governments around the world as digital collection and access has been systematically abused in almost every major developed nation. Until governments can return confidence in their actions and motivations Avoid an even low chance 1984 scenario is more important than making law enforcement/counter terrorism do their jobs the old fashion way.
- pif 11y ago> digital collection and access has been systematically abused in almost every major developed nation. I understand that the NSA issue was a bad surprise for many many people but, actually, who has been damaged by those practices?
- rbcgerard 11y agoSo if some stalker has been spying on your children over their web cam, but you/they never find out no one was damaged? If a tree falls in the woods...
- pif 11y agoIn practice, if I never know, no one has been damaged. Furthermore, if the FBI has been watching over the stalker and they arrest him as soon as he approaches my house, that's good!
- pixl97 11y agoIs anyone damaged if I sit in a tree outside your house and watch you take a shower through a crack in the window? Before I am discovered no one is, but after I am discovered there can be a significant amount of mental anguish.
- im3w1l 11y agoYou talk about centuries, in the mid 19th century only 10% of the world could even read or write. The vast majority of what governments want to access would have previously been said face to face without any records.
- guelo 11y agoA smartphone and the network services that power it have way more information then any personal journal ever did. It has every one you're associated with, every topic you're interested in, everywhere you've been, etc. Society did not fall apart back when the government did not have access to the complete life record of every potential criminal.
- partomniscient 11y agoYet the government, the corporations _and_ the criminals now all want access to the complete life record of every citizen.
- Zigurd 11y agoOur government, nor any government, has ever been able to do the impractical, never mind the provably impossible. The question is not whether we are restraining the government from knocking down some special doors. The question is more like whether we are preventing the government from using telepathy or defying gravity. No, nobody is preventing that except reality itself.
- dbpokorny 11y agoOur government has been prevented from knocking down whichever door it has wanted to by things like guns and revolutions. The elite have been revealed as perverts and mass murderers. Rip their genitals out. Kill their children. Fuck government. There will be blood in the streets.
- yoklov 11y agoAt the risk of invoking a meme... That escalated quickly.
- Zigurd 11y ago"Let's have a dirty war on authoritarians" is the mirror image of Comey's threat that Congress will enact some horrible law if a terrorist uses encryption. A more palatable description of that threat would not be out of place in this debate.
- dang 11y agoThis breaks the HN guidelines badly, as have some other of your recent comments. We ban accounts that do that, so please don't do that. Instead, post civil and substantive comments, and if you're not in a civil and substantive mood, please wait until you are. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- cft 11y agoIt used to be possible to destroy evidence: shred letters, burn receipts. There are plenty of legitimate reasons to do it. If the encryption is crippled, in the cloud based world the evidence of all your electronic communications will be indestructible, for the first time in history.
- cyphar 11y ago> >Various government agencies are crooning that they should be able to knock down whichever doors they please because they're the government. > I think this analogy is apt but it actually works against the author's point. Our government has legally been allowed to knock down whichever door it has wanted to for centuries assuming it has received the proper warrants. An encryption door cannot be knocked down. That is a very scary problem for the government and law enforcement. Things like personal notes, journals, communications all used to be accessible to the government through warrants. Now that information is all locked away behind encryption. Well, there was nothing stopping someone from writing their journals or notes in code so nobody could understand them. There is a question of whether someone would be forced to explain the code used for the notes. But the current scheme would be akin to the government requiring schools to spread misinformation about how to make a secure cipher and making it illegal to write a book about how to make a secure cipher without making the cipher broken. This is a huge shift in how we think about information and learning. There appears to be a general mystery about software as though technology has changed our underlying morals. It hasn't. If you reframe moral questions about software as moral questions about other things, the answers become more obvious. For example, the morals behind free software become immediately obvious if you consider mathematics or even things like blueprints (since a software program is both the design and implementation in a way). Of course there's the danger of a false parallel (and you might argue that I've drawn such a parallel), but I think my argument holds.
- thwarted 11y agoThings like personal notes, journals, communications all used to be accessible to the government through warrants. Now that information is all locked away behind encryption. This is a huge shift in the way governments fight crime. They only think that information is locked away behind encryption. There is no proof that the information they seek actually exists in the white-noise they claim it does unless the plaintext is recovered.
- threatofrain 11y agoI think the problem is that while the consequences of encryption on society has enough pros and cons to be gray, the sides that people choose are not at all gray. One side wants a backdoor and the other side doesn't. There's absolutely no way to draw a compromise on that. What does meeting down the middle between these two sides even mean? Law enforcement will always want as much power and legal protection as possible. It's the people who may or may not yield. It's the people who are going to budge on this issue. I also think that the effect sizes on the pro vs. con debate of encryption has been overblown, and that it will be many years before we get a body of literature on which to anchor claims of magnitudes in our debate. That being said, I think that leading the discussion on anti-encryption with discussions of terrorism and child porn is dishonest on its face. They're dishonestly exaggerated in effect size, and terrorism is the worse of the bunch, as the war on terror has costed mountains more than terrorism itself, both in money and in life. Unfortunately, these are often the top discussion points for any encryption debate.
- CWuestefeld 11y agoOur government has legally been allowed to knock down whichever door it has wanted to for centuries assuming it has received the proper warrants. That's mostly true, but not completely. There are a number of doors that have always been barred: - Self-incrimination - Incrimination of a spouse - Attorney-client relationship - Minister/priest - parishioner relationship - Doctor - patient relationship (?) The doctor simply cannot force you to bear witness against yourself. Nor can they force your attorney to reveal what you said to him. Some of these examples have a sort of exception, where a doctor or an attorney must give warning it they know that the subject person is going to commit murder, for example. But that's not the same as saying that the government can go back and look at past communications.