4 ms·
That can easily be made to look ridiculous: Does it become speech again after I disassemble it to find out how it works? At what point wasn't it speech?
by Zigurd 11y ago
That can easily be made to look ridiculous: Does it become speech again after I disassemble it to find out how it works? At what point wasn't it speech?
- rayiner 11y agoIt's not speech if you're not communicating an idea with it. You build a sculpture out of bricks it's speech. You take it apart and build an outhouse, it's not speech. It's not the substance of the thing that makes it speech or not. It's whether a human is using it to communicate ideas with other humans.
- MrLeap 11y agoNot trying to be pedantic, but doesn't an outhouse communicate messages? For instance "there's probably human waste here.", "Poop inside this rather than next to it" etc.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoIf you take a sculpture apart then it no longer conveys the same information. The code cryptographers use to communicate ideas is the same code the computer can execute. Are you contending that the same information is speech sometimes but not other times? What if the thing you're going to do with the information hasn't even been decided yet at the time of dissemination?
- wyldfire 11y agoAll of the points in this thread which indicate a distinction between what is and is not speech are all based on the legal precedents up until this point. The US legal system finds precedents valuable, but there's always an opportunity to find some new distinction or test. SCOTUS can make special distinction for encryption because implementations in practice are both a tool with independent utility and communicate an idea.
- Zigurd 11y agoAnthonyMouse has already clarified: It's the same information. My question, to which you are not responsive was: At what point does the same information magically become not speech? You are relying on perception, not on reality. It's always the same information. But it's easier to perceive it being a cog or lever inside a computer. But we all know that code is code. Compiled, decompiled, encrypted, compressed, translated, etc. It's all code all the time, and it's all speech all the time. You are bordering on some kind of Deepak Chopra-esque quantum mysticism that says humans must perceive speech in order for it to be speech.
- rayiner 11y ago> You are bordering on some kind of Deepak Chopra-esque quantum mysticism that says humans must perceive speech in order for it to be speech. Speech is a thing humans do, not a characteristic of bits or bricks or black armbands. The First Amendment doesn't protect particular types of things. It protects communications between humans. If one human isn't using a thing to communicate to other humans, it's not speech.
- Zigurd 11y ago> If one human isn't using a thing to communicate to other humans, it's not speech. Imagine a coder refusing an order from the FBI to create a tool. She is refusing to translate her thoughts into code. What is that other than refusing an attempt to compel speech? There is only one human in this picture. But the code an FBI order is attempting to extract from her brain is still speech.
- harryh 11y agoPutting your hands above your head can be speech: http://c.fastcompany.net/multisite_files/fastcompany/imagecache/620x350/poster/2014/08/3034486-poster-p-1-hands-up-dont-shoot.jpg http://c.fastcompany.net/multisite_files/fastcompany/imageca... But law enforcement can still tell you to "Stop and put your hands above your head!" The former is the communication of an idea. The latter is just a physical movement. Even though it's the exact same action.