3 ms·
What's dubious about it? It's saying that "no, you can't just reframe an act to focus on the speech (communicative aspect) and automatically inherit free speec
by SilasX 11y ago
What's dubious about it? It's saying that "no, you can't just reframe an act to focus on the speech (communicative aspect) and automatically inherit free speech protections".
Example: "What? What's the problem? All I did was the send the signal 100100111011110[...] to my computer. I have the right to say '1', don't I? I have the right to say '0', yeah? So I must have the right to say '100100111011110[...]'. The fact that this triggered a destruction of the evidence on my hard drive is totally irrelevant, because we established I have the right to say '100100...', don't infringe on that, man."
- swombat 11y agoAh, but the point of free speech is not that you are shielded from the consequences of the action of your speech. In your example, giving instructions that destroys evidence can certainly make you guilty of obstruction of justice or some other similar crime. But the point is, the government cannot either compel you to give those instructions, or compel you to not give them. They don't have the right to do that - at least not until they've convicted you of a crime that allows them to restrict your rights. If you're a free citizen, you can give whatever instructions to your computer you damn well please - and then face the consequences, which may be to make you a criminal. What the government ends up arguing in the Apple case, is they want to make you work to figure out what a "10101..." is that will break your own products and make you say it (to the right phone... and then the next phone, and the next). This, they want to do, even though you have not committed any crime. That is the issue at stake. As a free, lawful person you have the right to decide for yourself whether you're going to say something that you disagree with ethically and commercially. The FBI wants to take away your right to make that decision. They want, without even having legislated on the topic, to force you to say what they want you to say "because terrorists".
- ambulancechaser 11y agothe court decision cited only took up source code, and not compiled object code, precisely because source code is meant to be read by humans. Also, the right to normal "spoken" speech can be abrogated when it is a call to immediate action, and it may not be a stretch that issuing a command to destroy evidence--a crime-- would be an unprotected communication towards immediate action. With regard to publishing the encryption algorithm, the court found that he wasn't "refram[ing] an act to focus on speech" as you say but was engaging in the standard way that cryptologists communicate ideas: source code.