6 ms·
Why Messaging Startup Slack Keeps Raising Money It Doesn’t Need
- ajmurmann 11y agoIRC -> Campfire -> Hipchat and now Slack. I don't understand why large parts of the industry made these transitions, but it seems like for some reason we like to collectively abandon one chat solution and move on to the next hip one. Not sure why that will be different. I am not seeing Warren Buffet's famous moat and am thus not bullish on Slack.
- obilgic 11y agoICQ -> MSN -> Facebook -> Snapchat
- kamilafsar 11y agox86 Assembly -> C -> C++ -> JavaScript edit: Okay, I get why I'm being downvoted. :) But I just wanted to say, apparently in a vague way, that evolutions happen. People don't invest their precious time just because something is "hip". Apparently they solve a problem of their predecessor.
- atomic_cheese 11y agoC++ to JS is a pretty huge jump. C++ -> Java -> JS might work better.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoMore like LISP -> ML's -> C++, Java, C#, Ocaml -> Rust, Julia, Clojure, and the other better ones. :P
- ajmurmann 11y agoFacebook's userbase is still going strong though. Facebook also has a moat, since you cannot just move, because Facebook is where your friends are. With Slack, my company can decide to move and there are no other dependencies on anything external. We just move and that's it.
- toyg 11y agoThe moat is the integration points. The real differentiators for Slack are centralized history (better than IRC) and easy web endpoints for integration (better than pretty much anyone else). After a company invests significantly in a myriad of integration tools (both external and homegrown), they have little incentive to move. That's Slack's moat. Still, they have no real presence in the consumer space and that makes them vulnerable to the first player that can really cater to both businesses and consumers. As it is, consumer vendors (MS/Skype, Facebook, Google) are fumbling in the biz space, but that will not last forever. Edit: have a look at Slack 3rd-party apps for what i mean by integration. Because it's so easy to build them, there are tons.
- ajmurmann 11y agoWhen you say integration, I assume that goes beyond the chat bots that we have seen on other platforms since ages?
- yeukhon 11y agoYou forgot Yahoo Messenger and AIM. Before Snapchat it was iMessage, WhatsApp (still extremely popular). ICQ -> MSN & Yahoo Messenger & AIM -> SMS (sidekick phone!) -> iMessage & Facebook (the age of iPhone) -> WhatsApp -> Snapchat Hey, 56k was a real thing ;-)
- gkoberger 11y agoAside from it's zealous following that the others never enjoyed, Slack is also becoming a true platform. None of the other services had so many companies building integrations on top of them.
- ceejayoz 11y agoIt helps that Slack is spending $40M (plus another $40M from their investors) to encourage that. http://www.entrepreneur.com/article/254078 http://www.entrepreneur.com/article/254078
- ihuman 11y ago> None of the other services had so many companies building integrations on top of them I disagree. While there is no centralized list of IRC bots (because IRC isn't centralized), there is an uncountable number of IRC bots and libraries for people to make their own.
- Mandatum 11y ago"companies", not services. Aside from tech companies, IRC was never adopted by wider industries. We've been using it amongst a primarily operations-based company which relied on Email and Lync previously.
- moultano 11y agoI've already seen groups moving on from slack to other services.
- jinushaun 11y agoBut WHY did so many people decide to build Slack integration? It's not like HipChat and Campfire didn't have APIs. I say follow the money. My theory is that Slack has influential investors who were extremely successful in selling hype.
- ianremsen 11y agoI still really do not get why technical people don't just use IRC with a decent client (Hexchat?)
- giancarlostoro 11y agoKonversation is really nice and cleaned up, runs on every OS like HexChat / XChat does. Slack has a lot of sugar coating compared to any IRC client I've ever used, and I'm surprised nobody's beefed up an IRC client yet to "compete" with Slack. Some clients have really nice features though.
- subway 11y agoBecause a new IRC client without widespread protocol extensions means everyone currently using IRC will hate people using the new client due to the fact there is no place to hide metadata. See: Microsoft Comic Chat
- giancarlostoro 11y agoNot every new feature has to be a protocol extension though? Some clients just lack some sugar coating client-sided features. As for protocol extensions, you could always just disable them in-client on servers that don't support said extensions if anything. But my focus is on making more cleaned up IRC clients, a lot of them feel like they're stuck in time when I know there's lots of things that could be done to them to both make them user-friendlier for newcomers and make them a little more convenient to use.
- jypepin 11y agobecause businesses don't have only technical people, and you don't want to have multiple chat systems, which will eventually bring worst communication between different groups of people. If technical people are on IRC and all the other people are on hipchat, how do you make the 2 groups communicate?
- deleted 11y ago
- draw_down 11y agoI do. It's so ridiculous to me that people keep comparing it to IRC. It isn't IRC.
- x0x0 11y agoreason I love slack: I never see the android client in the top consumers of my battery. I'm being forced/fighting converting to hipchat, and if I let their client run on my phone, it's regularly in the top battery consumers. Oh, and notifications on my phone work great. I'm not sure how no one else can make this happen, but it appears to be the case.
- hobs 11y agoDesktop client or web client + animated gifs = my cpu fan starts spinning.
- IgorPartola 11y agoPersonally I went from IRC to Slack. As much as I like the IRC model (decentralized, open protocol) it just lacked so much that even the best client could not fix. Practically speaking, Slack is actually really good. I enjoy using it. I think the progression you are seeing is just an IRC exodus followed by people looking for an minimum viable solution, which may or may not end with Slack.
- mchahn 11y agoContinually raising money means the current stockholders, including people recently hired,are being diluted and are seeing their percentage shrink. This won't matter in the short term as the valuation soars, but it definitely will matter when the company matures and the end value is worth less.
- harryh 11y agoThat's only true if the money is spent unprofitably.
- vram22 11y ago> the end value is worth less. Just realized: the meaning changes a lot if you remove the space between worth and less :)
- encoderer 11y agoWell, the idea is that employees will own a little less of a company that now has $150MM more on it's balance sheet.
- taneq 11y agoBecause if they keep raising money then their valuation keeps going up, and people will think they're a good investment and keep giving them money based on their rising valuation. There's a word for that kind of structure.
- gkoberger 11y ago"Venture Capital"? (I know that's not the P word you're going for, but alas...)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI always thought it was close enough in many times in practice. ;)
- mistercow 11y agoTo be a Ponzi scheme (which I assume is what you mean), a key factor is massaging new investments to look like revenue, and using it to pay earlier investors. I see no reason to think that Slack is doing anything like that.
- rtpg 11y agoIn the NYTimes interview with Butterfield, he was clear that the money is because it's so easy to raise money right now. Having a huge battlechest is useful for being able to try risky new verticals without risking future growth too much. Like how they purchased that video chat startup and integrate that with Slack. He also talked about having cash to be able to give more to employees in the various situations, since stock options are useless in the case where Slack won't be public for 20 years.
- MBlume 11y ago...isn't this what an IPO is for?
- pori 11y agoIn a world that makes sense: probably. Keep in mind, Slack is not only raising money because it can but also because the public markets would throttle it like the companies had been in 2015. That said, Butterfield's move to raise more money simply to be attract more recruits sounds completely crazy. But hey, it's only crazy if it doesn't work. He seems to understand the awkward position his company is in. As covered in a TC article, Butterfield is prepping his company for the public markets even though there are no real plans to do so. This is evidenced by the near profitability Slack has now. Link to relevant article: http://techcrunch.com/2015/11/24/ready-to-pounce/ http://techcrunch.com/2015/11/24/ready-to-pounce/
- emcq 11y agoWhat I find confusing is that he says compensation is crazy at companies like Google, where employees can sell their equity on a public market with an expected value significantly above zero. Does this mean they are fundraising to pay their staff more in salary, or hoping that repeatedly diluting their private stock somehow makes Slack preferable?
- redwood 11y agoThis just means that the slowdown that everyone is anticipating this year has not yet set in across-the-board or across all Institutional Investor segments. Thesefolks at Slack will probably represent the last major round before everyone starts thinking "what have I done?". At this point I think a lot of the larger rounds are not even being publicized because they'd be so ridiculed. I understand raising money if you get amazing terms. But the hubris of a chat company with this kind of overvaluation boggles my mind
- redwood 11y agoThis just means that the slowdown that everyone is anticipating this year has not yet set in across-the-board or across all Institutional Investor segments. Thesefolks at Slack will probably represent the last major round before everyone starts thinking "what have I done?". At this point I think a lot of the larger rounds are not even being publicized because they'd be so ridiculed. I understand raising money if you get amazing terms. But the hubris of a chat company with this kind of overvaluation boggles my mind