6 ms·
DRM Non-Aggression on the Table at W3C
- JoshTriplett 11y agoThis seems like a good idea in principle. However, the people most likely to bring a DMCA suit are not participating members of the W3C and thus not subject to this pact. The major media production houses can sit back, let others build EME for them, use it, and wield the DMCA over that use.
- m0dest 11y agoWidevine (Google) and PlayReady (Microsoft) are the top EME DRM providers. Google and Microsoft are both on the EME working group. The critical question is whether rightsholders can use the DMCA (or local equivalent) to sue someone for circumventing DRM technology that isn't their own. If not, if the only party capable of enforcing anticircumvention is the DRM vendor itself, then this could be very effective.
- DanielDent 11y agoOne pragmatic approach would be to continue to support existing DRM -- but only for the largest most established existing players like Netflix. This would make DRM a problem for the content providers, because Netflix would then have a monopoly on the ability to distribute content with DRM. That's not good for their ability to have any leverage while negotiating. A similar situation played out with iTunes, and we've got DRM-free music available for sale now.
- tinalumfoil 11y ago> Netflix would then have a monopoly on the ability to distribute content with DRM To rephrase Archer, "Do you want the DOJ to be involved in the creation of (global) web standards through antitrust lawsuits? Because that's how you get the DOJ involved in the creation of web standards through antitrust lawsuits."
- DanielDent 11y agoI'm not sure there would be market harm from this outcome, which would be required for the DoJ to intervene. Content creators would remain free to license their content using their own technologies. Apple has successfully shut down people that created implementations compatible with Apple's DRM. To be clear, these people were not breaking Apple's DRM. They were "protecting content" using DRM that was iTunes/iPod compatible, and Apple shut that down.
- TerryADavis 11y agoYou must make buring CD/DVD/Blu-ray easy for data. I will force you to, soon enough. It's just going to be a mess you must pay for if you clusterfuck it.
- shmerl 11y agoDRM is a disease. They might mitigate symptoms (corrupted anti-circumvention laws), but this sickness must be uprooted at its source to be really fixed. W3C made a great disservice for the Web by accepting DRM in the standard legitimizing it in the process.
- Umn44 11y agoNot going to happen. Just look at what happened to Videogames all upcoming major AAA releases have some form of online DRM in them. They are even changing the marketing and dropping 'drm' and covering it up with marketing speak "oh we intended as multiplayer" (yeah right). Taking advantage of the publics stupidity and ignorance.
- njharman 11y agoDRM is a symptom. Perpetual copyright is the diseas.
- tremon 11y agoThe disease is using technical measures to enforce laws.
- d0lph 11y agoUsing technical measure to enforce law is a necessity, the over-stepping of bounds is the disease.
- njharman 11y agoyeah, I don't know. For an imagined law "government can't violate privacy" I'd feel much better with strong encryption (a technical measure) then trusting government to prosecute and jail its employees when they violate law.
- tptacek 11y agoAs long as major content providers want it, there is going to be DRM one way or the other. It is not in fact within W3C's power to prevent that. The only influence W3C has on DRM is the form it takes: is it implemented through (somewhat) standardized means, using the building blocks of web technology provided by browser vendors, or is it implemented through black-box plugins that we know, after 15+ years of experience, end-users will install. I have never really understand the role W3C is supposed to play as a pressure point for DRM.
- azakai 11y ago> As long as major content providers want it, there is going to be DRM one way or the other. It's not so simple. Content providers want to distribute on the web. Yes, they have the ability to just pull out and avoid that space entirely, but that's not good for them. The web needs their content, but they also need the web. In other words, the W3C saying no to DRM would apply pressure in the right direction. That suggests positions can be shifted. And we have seen them shift before, with music downloads, which used to be DRM'ed, but no longer are.
- zanny 11y agoExcept the web doesn't really need their content. The web exists and will continue to flourish regardless of the availability of commercial hollywood films and television on it. It got this far without ruining open standards, and the MAFIAA lobby forced DRM bullshit upon it because they fear for their long term viability. That is a sign they were losing the battle, and they absolutely were with the rise of youtube, facebook video, twitch, etc - alternative video sources were / are starting to get professional, with many major youtube channels having production crew and proper film / showmaking. The web would have been absolutely fine without them, but they knew they would not survive without the web long term, especially internationally.
- tptacek 11y agoIn exactly what way would the W3C "saying no to DRM" apply any pressure at all? The W3C cannot ban plugins.
- 11y ago
- irq-1 11y agoIt wasn't so many years ago that the solution would have been a proprietary patent with FRAND (Fair, Reasonable, and Non-Discriminatory) licensing and payment. Free and Open Source made the payment impossible, so companies had to change. The proprietary control through patents was tempered by standard bodies excluding such contributions (like W3C [0]), or patent disclaimers (like Microsofts Community Promise [1]), or patent pooling (like MPEG LA). So if we want to eliminate DRM, without hoping for another miracle from Apple, we should use the large market share of open source software. Maybe that means changing licenses (like a BSD 4-clause 'no DRM' license). Maybe it means making client/server software that just doesn't work with DRM, closing down web based DRM, and forcing Hulu etc... to each implement their own clients on every platform (as it was before EME). Maybe get a Netflix competitor to use AGPL3 server and clients, that won't work with distributors that demand DRM. [0] https://www.w3.org/Consortium/Patent-Policy-20040205/#sec-Licensing https://www.w3.org/Consortium/Patent-Policy-20040205/#sec-Li... [1] https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/openspecifications/dn750984 https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/openspecifications/dn750984
- echelon 11y agoA viral no-DRM clause in a variety of open source licenses sounds like a great idea! How could we go about promulgating such a thing?
- AaronFriel 11y agoIt's a non-starter called GPL3. While I'm not a lawyer, my understanding is that many businesses consider the GPL3 and its extended anti-tivoization, anti-patent provisions dangerous. They may be misguided, I won't comment on that here. I will just say that my impression is that such an anti-DRM clause exists, and the license that uses it has many detractors.
- spriggan3 11y agoWas it tested in court in US ? Were some businesses sued for violation of a GPL3 license ? if yes by whom ? it's just a question.
- stegosaurus 11y agoAs a sort of external observer who doesn't really 'do' big media, I'm left wondering why content providers even bother with DRM at all. Any insiders about to provide some sort of perspective? All of the content is all over torrent sites. The general public are 'non-savvy', or unwilling to take the risk, and seem to continue paying to netflix'n'chill. So I don't really understand why this is even a thing. It feels like anyone savvy enough to save a HTML5 video and copy it to a USB drive would be savvy enough to open a torrent site. What gives?
- JeremyBanks 11y agoEthics.
- Flimm 11y agoDRM isn't effective at stopping the data from getting out into torrents, but it is effective at other things, one of which is mentioned by the article: it makes researching copying and bypassing copy restrictions illegal. There are few other I explained in my answer here: http://security.stackexchange.com/a/25175/15712 http://security.stackexchange.com/a/25175/15712
- duncan_bayne 11y agoSome past discussion on this topic: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7055016 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7055016
- majormajor 11y agoOverall, this whole argument seems like the web being well behind the curve and debating about approaches to take to yesterday's problem (or perceived problem, I've yet to see real harm done by DRM on Netflix) when meanwhile things are largely passing them by. Consumption is moving to smart TVs, Rokus, iPads, etc. So if you want a threat to the "open web" the appification of the world is where you'll find it. I'm not sure it'll be stopped either way (or even that this trend is so terrible), but religious objections to DRM - to push things that way even faster - aren't going to do anything to slow that train down.