4 ms·
I find it interesting that all those who claim IRC is insufficient or is too hard to implement (they say the same about XMPP) don't ever seem to say what is so
by chris_wot 11y ago
I find it interesting that all those who claim IRC is insufficient or is too hard to implement (they say the same about XMPP) don't ever seem to say what is so hard, or mention the features that are missing.
- chris_wot 11y agoSeriously, what is going on here? It seems any and every comment about IRC or XMPP is being downvoted to oblivion. If someone is astroturfing, I suggest you stop immediately.
- Karunamon 11y agoBecause such comments are at this point inane and uninteresting. As has been mentioned ad nauseum, Slack and friends are winning because IRC is a pain and lacks really basic creature comforts like offline messages and anything but text. I'm downvoting them as I see them for this reason. Anyone saying "Why not IRC?" to the question of "Slack alternative?" is being willfully ignorant at this point. Same goes to those who accuse people of astroturfing absent evidence other than "$ideaILike is being downvoted".
- chris_wot 11y agoOnly as inane and uninteresting as the comment you just posted. You can't impute motives why someone might ask that question. You may feel it has been repeated ad nauseum but it's quite possible those asking the question haven't read the previous HN comments. At this point, you come over as an arrogant jerk.
- brongondwana 11y agoIf you never read any comments that tell you what's so hard, then I guess you don't see them. To avoid repeating myself: http://lists.lca2016.linux.org.au/pipermail/chat/2016-January/000139.html http://lists.lca2016.linux.org.au/pipermail/chat/2016-Januar... As soon as you say "run a bouncer" you limit your audience severely. Without a bouncer, you're a transient in the world of IRC. Doubly so if you have the temerity to want to interact from a mobile device that pops on and off networks all the time.
- voltagex_ 11y agoI was in the LCA2016 IRC channel and at LCA2016 in person. I really wish we could have CCC [1] levels of "audience participation" because it allows people to interact with the conference who may not normally be able to attend. The live streaming was really well done but I think there needs to be One True Chat Channel for LCA2017. Maybe that means using Slack or similar and swallowing a bit of FOSS pride for a while. [1]: https://events.ccc.de/congress/2015/wiki/Congress_Everywhere https://events.ccc.de/congress/2015/wiki/Congress_Everywhere and yes, they use IRC. LCA's audience is a bit different