4 ms·
Classification of course, assigning entities to categories according to their attributes, is itself logic. Making a distinction between "reasoning by analogy"
by YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago
Classification of course, assigning entities to categories according to their attributes, is itself logic.
Making a distinction between "reasoning by analogy" and "reasoning with logic" is actually pretty weird. Analogy is also (informal) logic - drawing attention to the common characteristics of objects and reasoning about their therefore shared attributes. What Hinton really means, at least as I understand it, is "reasoning with approximation" not by analogy.
But, approximation is what you do when you _can't_ do logic. It's your recourse when you can't do the optimal, which is indeed, reasoning with logic according to knowledge.
Hinton is advocating that, because we managed to get ahead with some hard problems by approximating solutions, we should forget about ever getting a good understanding of the problems. But that's dangerous, defeatist and goes against the way we've progressed pretty much throughout all of human civilisation so far.