4 ms·
I really dislike the community part of Imgur as well, mostly because the people seem weird and childish, but also because it fails to add any value. Attempting
by mrweasel 11y ago
I really dislike the community part of Imgur as well, mostly because the people seem weird and childish, but also because it fails to add any value.
Attempting to add context is a good idea, but Imgur fails at that. Images on Imgur isn't tagged or titled right, which makes search completely useless. If you see an image, and want to find it, even later that same day, you can pretty much forget about it. The community part of Imgur might even make the problem worse, because the users just stay within the confines of Imgur, meaning they don't feel the need for tagging, good titles and search.
Take this example: http://imgur.com/gallery/X4R7y http://imgur.com/gallery/X4R7y the title is "useful for arguments", except it's just a bunch of jumbled gif, there are no useful tags, no discover-ability or search-ability.
The community part shows up, because regardless of the original intent, sites do need to make money. There are no real way for sites like Imgur to make money, other than attempting to sell ads. Having a community helps sell those ads.
- DanBC 11y ago> I really dislike the community part of Imgur as well, mostly because the people seem weird and childish, but also because it fails to add any value. Like /r9k/ it had a great three months, and then everyone found it.
- surge 11y agoThis seems like the story of every great Internet site, ever. It's great until the lowest common denominator finds it then it goes to crap. Reddit is only spared because you can unsubscribe from default subreddit's and find more niche sub-reddit's that attract a niche audience or subset of users that are less likely to "sh#tpost" for lack of a better term. Not to say all new users are bad or don't contribute anything new, but the noise to signal ratio is way worse the more people pile on and start becoming an echo chamber. I've even seen it a little with HN as its gained popularity, but thankfully this site is so niche its not too bad. But I kind of wish I could do that with other community sites and social media. I know a lot of people loved twitter, or digg, or whatever back in the day before the celebrities, media, and extended relatives caught on.
- CaptSpify 11y agoThere was a picture that I remember describing "The problem with social media" and it had a couple of people sharing something they thought interesting with friends. Then five more people joined and it got noisy. Then a bunch of people showed up, spouting irrelevant noise. Then the first group of people left. Unfortunately I think it's inevitable. If only there was a site where I could search for images like that |;)
- surge 11y agoYeah, I've accepted that, and for the most part, usually something new comes along and replaces it. The trick is to find where people went after X site went to crap. Sometimes though, a suitable replacement doesn't always crop up. I haven't seen a good imgur replacement.
- jnky 11y agoAh, yes. Eternal September. A problem almost as old as the WWW. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September
- CM30 11y agoI'm not sure this is necessarily an unavoidable fate for internet sites, even communities. You can keep the signal to noise ratio decent if you've got an active team of moderators, fairly heavy pruning of content that doesn't add anything to the conversation and the willingness to say no, my site doesn't offer 'freedom of speech'. Unfortunately, most big sites seem to be built on the 'leave it as a complete free for all with no moderation whatsoever' model, which immediately stops working the minute the memberbase expands from early adopters to every Tom, Dick and Harry. That's why Reddit, Twitter, etc have had so many problems. They were built with the idea of 'anyone can say virtually anything' in mind, then realised it would lead to massive amounts of trolling and personal attacks and questionable content, then dug themselves an even deeper hole by trying to moderate the site in woefully biased ways.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago