4 ms·
There is a very good reason for that which is explained very eloquently in this speech. Really worth a look. https://youtu.be/dXQPL9GooyI https://youtu.be/dXQP
by ThomPete 11y ago
There is a very good reason for that which is explained very eloquently in this speech. Really worth a look.
https://youtu.be/dXQPL9GooyI https://youtu.be/dXQPL9GooyI
"You cannot find things by looking for them"
Any person who have ever tried to solve problems (not just rationalize next steps based on previous findings) will know that there is really something unfruitful and irreproducible about logical reasoning.
One of the primary reasons is that logical reasoning you make is based on it's premise. As an example you can rationalize your way through Game of Thrones as long as your premise is set to accept a number of sub-conclusions. Or be a theologist rationalizing your way through the bible.
But this powerful process is also a cage which keeps you trapped inside the same logical consequences of your premises.
And so to invent something new you have to be "irrational" to break out of the boundaries of the premise.
So the claim is not to abandon logic but the belief that problems are solved and inventions made by rational logical process alone. It turns out that most things are actually more trial and error which again also historically has some merit.
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago>> One of the primary reasons is that logical reasoning you make is based on it's premise. Yes, that's called the closed-world assumption. Something is true if you can prove it from the things you know. You know how else we call the "things you know"? Data. You know what else we do with data? Train machine learning algorithms. You know where machine learning algorithms would be if they abandoned their (implicit) closed-world assumption?
- ThomPete 11y agoWhere machines would be if they increased the available input sources? We know that as little as we know where a kid will end up when we put them into the world and they start to interact with it being the patter recognizing feedback loops that we are. The point is that premises allow us to make logical reasoning but the premises themselves are not necessarily logic or universally true or objective or any other notion of right or wrong. Look through history. Most of the really big innovations weren't a product of some objective but rather incidents and curious phenomena we never expected. Rational reasoning will take you some of the way as long as you have the premise, but the question is how to get to the premise.
- skybrian 11y agoIf a machine learning algorithm takes closed-world assumptions too far, it overfits the input data. We test whether it's working by testing it on data it hasn't seen. You can't tell whether overfitting is happening by just looking at the input data. You'd at least need a holdout set for testing.