3 ms·
There's no legal concept of that oft-asserted “fiduciary duty to maximize shareholder profits” and for a very good reason: it's almost never clear what the corr
by acdha 11y ago
There's no legal concept of that oft-asserted “fiduciary duty to maximize shareholder profits” and for a very good reason: it's almost never clear what the correct decision is until afterwards.
In this case, what are the odds that an overseas call center would cost more than anticipated (often the case), lower the quality of service and thus the company's reputation, or actually be enough to stop the downwards spiral rather than just signaling that you're in a low value-add commodity business?
- sinatra 11y ago> what are the odds that an overseas call center would cost more than anticipated (often the case), lower the quality of service and thus the company's reputation, or actually be enough to stop the downwards spiral rather than just signaling that you're in a low value-add commodity business? I would imagine that a company as large as LS would have used some analysis and external/internal data to estimate the overall costs of such a move (which would include the cost of lower quality of service etc). And they must have still found the move cost-effective. It's slightly insulting to LS employees to think that they would know less about the cost-effectiveness of this move than us. Moreover, this move seems drastic. When you're making such drastic moves, you're likely doing so to be able to survive. In such cases, lower quality of customer service and poor signals etc take a back seat.
- acdha 11y agoThe argument isn't that LS management knows less but rather that they're trying to balance multiple demands. An investor's interests end when they cash out, so it's very common for CEOs to face pressure to make decisions which are likely to be profitable in the short-term, but unless they're planning to leave at the same time rhey have to consider the risks to long-term sustainability. Things like customer support and R&D are classic targets for that because they tend to involve many jobs which don't directly generate revenue, and the negative effects often aren't visible for years but the savings show up in the next quarterly report.
- swampthing 11y agoSorry, this is not getting at the core of your assertion, but what do you mean by: > There's no legal concept of the oft-asserted “fiduciary duty" ... I can assure you that "fiduciary duty" is very much a legal concept.
- acdha 11y agoSorry, yes, that could have been more precise. There's a common trope that executives have a fiduciary duty to maximize shareholder value, but that's not actually written into any sort of law for the reasons I mentioned — business is all about judgement calls trying to balance risks and trying to balance short and long-term prospects. I'll edit that to clarify. That doesn't mean that cost shouldn't be considered, only that there's no support for the assertion that “cost is definitely a more important factor” because reasonable people can quite legitimately come to different conclusions. I might think the overseas call center is reasonable, you might think that you'll be able to offer a better customer experience by keeping it in-house or with staff who work for you rather than contractors, etc. and only time will tell how true those predictions are.
- phonon 11y agoErr...I am guessing you have never been involved shareholder derivative lawsuit against the board then...happens all the time in M&A. http://www.pennstatelawreview.org/116/3/116%20Penn%20St.%20L.%20Rev.%20837.pdf http://www.pennstatelawreview.org/116/3/116%20Penn%20St.%20L... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revlon,_Inc._v._MacAndrews_%26_Forbes_Holdings,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revlon,_Inc._v._MacAndrews_%26....
- acdha 11y agoThat's a specialized edge-case and both of your links make the same point that I was making as the default rule for normal operations. There is usually considerable deference to business judgement but when a company is being sold you have an unusually simple situation where the timeframe is fixed and the value is precise. Notice how the situation is recognized as different from the normal operations we were talking about: > Accordingly, the board's actions are evaluated in a different frame of reference. In such a context, that conduct can not be judicially reviewed pursuant to the traditional business judgment rule, but instead will be scrutinized for reasonableness in relation to this discrete obligation.
- phonon 11y agoBest not to talk in absolutes then, Mr. "'There's no legal concept of that oft-asserted "fiduciary duty to maximize shareholder profits'" lol at M&A is a "specialized edge-case".