3 ms·
If you were to pick an octogenarian at random do you think it's more likely that they have very little experience/comfort with computers, or that they studied i
by pc86 11y ago
If you were to pick an octogenarian at random do you think it's more likely that they have very little experience/comfort with computers, or that they studied it in school and "remember when LaTeX was new"? That has nothing to do with demeaning anyone, and someone doesn't lose their dignity because they haven't been raised on a screen.
It's like any time someone mentions something that is statistically the most common scenario people can't wait to come out of the woodwork to exclaim how they had a different experience, so clearly the OP is wrong/mean-spirited/sexist/racist/ageist/whatever rather than just acknowledging they had a different experience.
The idea that older people, on average, are less comfortable with technology is not some meme that needs to die. It's a statistical reality.
- munin 11y agoit costs you nothing to say "less sophisticated user" and it captures the full range of your problem. you're not specifically trying to make your website easy for octogenarians to use - you want it to be usable by everyone, with no assumptions. why say something in an exclusive way when you could say it in an inclusive way?
- pc86 11y agoBecause context is a thing. Here, I will rewrite the text from the article with your suggestion: > Think a drunk UX expert is the worst challenge you can put your website through? You’re wrong. There’s one thing worse than that: A less sophisticated user. Here you can hire a less sophisticated user to torture your website. Not to mention the fact that the website in question is literally theuserismymom.com.
- munin 11y agoif I were branding a usability testing website I probably wouldn't name it "the user is my mom" but rather name it "we built a better idiot" or something. boom! now we're not sexist or ageist and it's clearer what the purpose of the website/company is.
- groovy2shoes 11y agoThat's really insensitive. One of my best friends is an idiot, and I don't appreciate you putting a whole group of people down. There are a lot of idiots who are genuinely good people.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 11y agoReplacing the exact phrase doesn't work precisely because the stereotype here is used in a demeaning way. The solution isn't to shrug and say, "Gosh, this rewrite is too hard for mortal man." It's to do a more complete rewrite. E.g.: > Even better than a drunk UX expert: an ordinary user. Developer Scotty Allen makes available his actual mom, a high school tutor, to give you her take on what's wrong with your web site. The difference for me between theuserismymom.com and the "moms are worse than drunk people" spin is respect. Scotty is promoting his mom as a savvy person. Whereas the, "so simple even your mom could use it" stereotype is typically lazy, sexist bullshit.
- wpietri 11y agoI totally believe that you don't intend to demean people. Why can't you believe that people are nonetheless demeaned by negative stereotypes? Seriously, pick half a dozens groups you are a part of and write down a negative stereotype for each one. How do you feel about those. When I was growing up, "nerd" was the stick used to beat me a lot. Were the things said about nerds statistically true? Often, yes. Were they true about me? Some yes, some no. Did the stereotyping help me in any way? Not really. Did it harm me? Definitely.
- stephenboyd 11y agoThe people in the US most statistically likely to be comfortable with technology are young, male, and white or Asian. So your reasoning suggests that it's OK to take any other group of people, pick one of their least sophisticated to represent them all, and call it statistical reality. How would you feel about The User is My Latino Neighbor, where instead of the user being Scotty's mom who happens to be computer-illiterate and stereotypically into quilting, it's his Latino neighbor who happens to be computer-illiterate and stereotypically working as a gardener? I don't even mean to pick on the site, just the defense of stereotypes that you're making.