4 ms·
Silent films is a genre of movies, but is "films by female directors" also a genre? It could be, but I would instantly question how we define a genre then. Wou
by belorn 11y ago
Silent films is a genre of movies, but is "films by female directors" also a genre? It could be, but I would instantly question how we define a genre then.
Would "films by insert sexual orientation directors" also be a genre? What about "films by left handed directors"? The simpson had a whole episode about discrimination against people with blond hair, so what about "films by blond directors"? I don't think i have ever said that a list of movies should directors with any specific attribute, nor that would I ever say that it shouldn't.
- mikeash 11y agoWhy is "a genre" fair game, but "a kind of director" not?
- belorn 11y agoLets compare Hollywood movies with bollywood, two genre and two locations. Historically, a Hollywood movie is a movie made in Hollywood for an american audience, and bollywood is movies made in Inida for an Indian audiences. However, film makers in Hollywood has done Bollywood movies in Hollywood, and Indian movie makers has made Hollywood movies in India. Can a male director make a "film by female director"? if not, then its not a genre. female directed and male directed style of movies could become a genre, and then we would see female directors make male directed styled movies, and male directors make female directed styled movies. The question is how we would define that style, specially if we want to avoid sexist generalization. Bollywood genre is categorized by a movie with a lot of songs and dances, love triangles, comedy and dare-devil thrills are all mixed up in a three-hour extravaganza with an intermission. Bollywood plots have tended to be melodramatic. How would you describe the female directed genre as?