3 ms·
Since I made the initial comment, I'll reply. > Would you be just as upset If by "just as upset", you mean "not upset at all, but rather curious", then yes, I
by StavrosK 11y ago
Since I made the initial comment, I'll reply.
> Would you be just as upset
If by "just as upset", you mean "not upset at all, but rather curious", then yes, I would be exactly as upset.
> Would you be just as upset about Spike Lee bending to his critics instead of sticking to his guns in that case?
I would wonder why he changed a list of something entirely personal to him after some people pointed out that he didn't include any films from the silent era. I am equally curious as to why the reply was "oh yeah, here are five films from women", rather than "oh yeah, I forgot a bunch of stuff, some including women". If anything, it sounds a bit patronizing to women filmmakers, that they're included as an afterthought.
A satisfying (to me) reply would be "holy shit guys I had a brain fart and was only thinking of men when compiling the list and completely forgot about my favorite female filmmakers, here they are, sorry about that, wow".
- mikeash 11y agoYou may not be upset, but a quick glance at the comments shows a ton of people who are quite upset that Lee responded to this criticism the way he did. You wonder why he changed a list of something personal to him after people gave him additional food for thought? Are your opinions so set in stone? If you compiled a list of top programming language features, could you not even conceive of adding more entries to it after publishing it and having people make suggestions? Why do people expect this stuff to be carved in stone from the beginning? Your hypothetical reply looks a lot like his real reply to me.
- StavrosK 11y agoI can definitely conceive of adding more features, but I can't conceive of adding more features that begin with a certain letter, since that has no bearing on whether they are good features or not.
- mikeash 11y agoImagine if letter bias was extremely common in society, to the extent that you find yourself unconsciously applying it yourself even if you don't want to. Would you still hold that stance?
- StavrosK 11y agoYou mean in a "wait I totally meant to add these features but didn't initially consider them because they started with the letter z" way?
- mikeash 11y agoI wouldn't go so far as "I totally meant to." More like, "On further reflection, these features starting with the letter Z have merit and belong on my list."
- StavrosK 11y agoI don't know, I find it completely foreign because I rarely know who directed a film. Of course, Spike Lee would know, but I don't know if the gender of the director would affect his opinion of a movie that much. That's what I find improbable in this specific case.
- untog 11y ago> since that has no bearing on whether they are good features or not. This isn't a list of "best movies", it's a list of "movies aspiring directors should see". I have to imagine that such a list would strive to show all the diversity that exists in the film-making world, not just the ones held up as empirically "best".
- ant6n 11y agoPretending that normative thinking didn't exist doesn't make it so, and doesn't help discriminated groups. In fact, it's part of the problem.