3 ms·
The FBI already has access to pretty much any locked door they want if they get a warrant. Their problem is that warrants don't work against encryption.
by slg 11y ago
The FBI already has access to pretty much any locked door they want if they get a warrant. Their problem is that warrants don't work against encryption.
- kbenson 11y agoThe front door is a less useful metaphor than your safe. We have safes in addition to locked front doors because it's accepted getting into the house is generally not that hard, whether you be law enforcement or a criminal.
- taf2 11y agoMy parents worked for the NSA before there was an NSA. A guy came in to do a talk about how there is no such thing as security. He had a table with a bunch of common locks and even some safes. He proceeded to unlock each one in a matter of seconds to demonstrate his point. Modern encryption however is changing the game. It's no longer true that security is just a matter of perception. It's becoming a reality and that makes for an interesting and bold new world we're entering.
- bduerst 11y agoMaybe, but the game is still the same. There are weak points for encryption just as there were weak points with the safe that he unlocked.
- maxerickson 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Security_Agency#World_War_II_and_its_aftermath https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Security_Agency#World... What did they do?
- taf2 11y agoIt's a secret - break codes and write code, ;). While the NSA was started in the 50s it was not widely known until the 70s https://www.eff.org/nsa-spying/timeline https://www.eff.org/nsa-spying/timeline
- slg 11y agoA warrant is just as effective against nearly all safes. I have little doubt that if a safe was in FBI custody as long as the San Bernardino shooter's phone has been, the FBI would have been able to legally and physically get whatever was inside. The FBI simply wants the digital world to mirror the physical world and a 100% unbreakable physical lock is almost impossible to produce in the physical world. It is easy to see why they would want that to be true in the digital world.
- merpnderp 11y agoIn this case, the digital world mirrors the physical world. Since this phone doesn't have secure enclave, they could trivially break into it. The fact that they've said they can't makes them liars. Very public liars. And are liars considered trustworthy? https://www.aclu.org/blog/free-future/one-fbis-major-claims-iphone-case-fraudulent https://www.aclu.org/blog/free-future/one-fbis-major-claims-... [EDIT for added link]
- visarga 11y ago> the FBI would have been able to legally and physically get whatever was inside. What if the safe has a self-destruct mechanism for the contents in case of breach?
- rietta 11y agoAnd what if government agencies bought that safe to handle classified material because it was certified to have met or exceeded the standards for handling such data. Then the FBI forces the safe manufacturer to make a way to get into the safe. Now the other agency can come after the manufacturer for lying to them during the procurement process because there is demonstrably a way for an unauthorized person to break into the safe.
- adrianN 11y agoGetting in a safe is also not that hard if you're the FBI, I think. I'm pretty sure that every safe can be cracked in a day or two without destroying whatever is inside.