3 ms·
"The charitable interpretation would be statistics: if 90+% of recognised films have been directed by men - and I'd expect more men to have directed films in, s
by dsr_ 11y ago
"The charitable interpretation would be statistics: if 90+% of recognised films have been directed by men - and I'd expect more men to have directed films in, say, the 1950s than the present day - it's not terribly unlikely that a list would feature only men through chance alone."
Can we get a statistician here, stat?
We have a jar with 9000 blue marbles and 1000 white marbles. We reach in, blindly, 87 times. What is the expectation that we have drawn 87 blue marbles?
We expect this one time in ten thousand. When we observe this in real life, we ordinarily suspect that the procedure is flawed in some way, rather than pure luck.
- Retric 11y ago10% seems high. From google: "Women Comprise 7% of Directors" .93^87 = 0.0018 However, what's the ratio among films not just directors? (can't find) How about women among top grossing films of all time? http://www.boxofficemojo.com/alltime/domestic.htm http://www.boxofficemojo.com/alltime/domestic.htm vs. http://www.thewrap.com/15-highest-grossing-movies-directed-by-women/13/ http://www.thewrap.com/15-highest-grossing-movies-directed-b... So: Frozen, Shrek, Twilight, Kung Fu Panda 2 .96^ 87 = 2.9% Looking at the top grossing list for women you see a lot of chick flicks and kids films. Arguably that's bias, but not vs. the director.
- tosseraccount 11y ago8% of people in prison are females. No. It's not random.
- facepalm 11y agoAre women making roughly the same type of films as men? Maybe his list simply reflected his interests?
- mootothemax 11y ago>We have a jar with 9000 blue marbles and 1000 white marbles. We reach in, blindly, 87 times. What is the expectation that we have drawn 87 blue marbles? >We expect this one time in ten thousand. When we observe this in real life, we ordinarily suspect that the procedure is flawed in some way, rather than pure luck. Doesn't that presume equal distribution? What if all the white marbles are at the bottom of the jar? Or stacked on one side? Just like me wondering about how many woman directed films in the 1950s, I think that there may be painful numbers of skews and presumptions that'd affect the final result. (although - mea culpa - yeah I was very lazy with that original comment)