5 ms·
I agree with your argument as far as it goes, but if you're responding to me, you're making a straw man argument. I was saying that living things (i.e. individ
by pmiller2 11y ago
I agree with your argument as far as it goes, but if you're responding to me, you're making a straw man argument. I was saying that living things (i.e. individual organisms) aren't very reliable; you're saying that life is very resilient. That's a true statement, but utterly non-responsive to the point I was making.
- taneq 11y agoIndividual organisms are incredibly reliable when you consider the range of functions they perform. Compare, say, a quadcopter drone (or any other small air vehicle) with a parrot. Lifespan without service or repair? Drone, weeks. Parrot, decades. Autonomy before recharging/refueling? Drone, 20 minutes. Parrot, hours to days. Cognitive faculties? Drone, slim to none. Parrot, long term autonomous in complex environments. Reproduction? We can't build things that do that at all yet, let alone pack one into a 1kg autonomous aircraft. Yes, we can build simple machines to replicate one function of a living creature, and those machines will be more reliable over short durations, but only because they are orders of magnitude simpler. You might as well call an LCD screen "unreliable" because it won't outlast a photograph.
- nnq 11y agoFrom modern evolutionary biology's perspective "individual organisms" are NOT the "basic units/modules etc." of life. The basic ones are genes at the core informational level level and species at more loose and macro level. So the living things to software analogy would be more like: - gene == source code of a program's module (like an "independently testable unit of code" - natural-selection + sex-based recombination are actually the tests) - ... (organizational levels with with no direct analogy to software go in between) - individual organism == set of processes (running instances of programs) running together with heavy inter-process communication Then at a higher level, genes and their manifestations constitute the "hardware" (more like a VM), run the software called "memes", with its own organizational patterns that are outside the field of biology. What you call living thing or individual organism is, from "life's perspective", closer to a transient group of running processes that can be killed at any time because their sources and binaries are safely stored as genes or memes. Your body and your psychological self are closer to "running threads of nginx on a particular server handling a particular set of requests" than to "the program nginx itself" in source or binary form :)
- mannykannot 11y agoIn a discussion, it is not unreasonable to say that if you widen your view a bit, you will find a greater truth.