4 ms·
I personally notice that a lot of government funded research goes to PIs of questionable intelligence that have merely mastered grantsmanship... How many brilli
by dnautics 11y ago
I personally notice that a lot of government funded research goes to PIs of questionable intelligence that have merely mastered grantsmanship... How many brilliant young scientists have had their careers cut short by being discouraged by the granting system instead of going on to make discoveries in science?
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoThe grant process is terrible. Let's fix it. Or are you implying that for some unspecified reason that would be impossible?
- dnautics 11y agoIt's impossible. Responsible government has to have a mechanism for accountability, and this is antithetical to basic science.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoBy that logic the only way to fund basic science is for independently wealthy scientists to fund their own research, since otherwise they would be accountable to someone. I expect the problematic accountability would be accountability for results, but why would that be necessary for government funded research? Negative results are progress, not failure. Now you know something doesn't work when you didn't before. On the other hand, if there was accountability for e.g. the research being reproducible, why would that be antithetical to science?
- dnautics 11y agoBecause protecting taxpayer money which is collected nonconsensually incurs a higher standard of accountability. Accountability is important because a scientist can claim basic science to engage in irresponsible dalliances, and cover by claiming "basic science". It happens all the time as a part of Grantsmanship
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoHow is the problem of irresponsible scientists different for the government than private funders? I can assure you that private funders want the highest standard of accountability available.
- dnautics 11y agoPrivate funders can be assumed to have taken that risk when choosing to spend their money. Public funders do not. Like it or not, for example, congress has continued to appropriate millions for "holistic" and "integrative" medicine research. When for the most part it was discovered to be bunk, they fired the chief administrator and redoubled efforts under the justification that "not enough had been spent to achieve a positive result"
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]