6 ms·
I think Apple was wrong to have picked to have this battle in such a poorly defended position. The stand would have been better made over a secure device they c
by mindslight 11y ago
I think Apple was wrong to have picked to have this battle in such a poorly defended position. The stand would have been better made over a secure device they couldn't unlock. But obviously I have to now root for Apple, hoping that a terrible intermediate precedent does not get set and that they're able to dissuade new laws as well.
At least the amended FBI request looks a lot less risky.
- mkhpalm 11y agoI'm not sure a device they couldn't unlock really solves the problem. Lets say they did have such a device. Couldn't the government just force them into building a back door even if they themselves can't unlock it? This is the underlying argument to me, and I feel a bit like a conspiracy theorist saying it. But based on the talk about Apple or Whatsapp or the lack of documented evidence for the latest FCC ruling about wifi radios. It feels more like the government is positioning itself to have private back door access to everything. Not to mention the president basically said just that while speaking at SXSW.
- mindslight 11y agoSure, which is why proprietary solutions are ultimately doomed if USG continues down its totalitarian path. But it would have been a tougher legal battle to constrain what types of software can be written in general, compared to just compelling Apple to unlock one specific device of interest using an existing backdoor. And it seems like once the easier precedent has been set, the worse one will be a much shorter leap.
- SturgeonsLaw 11y ago> It feels more like the government is positioning itself to have private back door access to everything That's exactly what it's doing. Total Information Awareness is more than just the name of a "cancelled" program, it's a concept which is inextricably interwoven throughout the entire intelligence community.
- mythz 11y agoApple did not pick this battle, how can you even think they would? the FBI carefully chose this case to break character and go public on despite Apple's request to have the case sealed. This tragedy is being exploited by the FBI in order to set a legal precedent to further their surveillance powers that would compel a Technology company to use their own resources against theirs and their customers best interests.
- mindslight 11y agoThe device in question is insecure. For example, if the proper subset of Apple employees' children were kidnapped, they'd be using their backdoor. As such, Apple could have acted how courts expect a commercial third party to act [0], issued a security advisory for the vulnerability, and made damn sure future devices were secure. Alas, doing so would undermine their model of maintaining a backdoor to owners' devices but only wanting to use it for commercial purposes. [0] A locksmith doesn't editorialize about which warrants to facilitate, and when he does, the government simply changes locksmiths. The novelty here is that Apple is supposedly the only locksmith that can unlock this lock, so USG wishes to compel them to engage. Given that they're an incorporated commercial entity, I don't hold out hope.