6 ms·
Patents and innovation in economic history [pdf]
- gumby 11y agoTL;DR: politicians and lazy academics typically consider patents to be the driver of new inventions. Turns out that research doesn't bear that out -- who knew?! In fact when patent laws are too strong or too broad, development slows down. Shocker! (Actually it's good to have someone actually look into the data and challenge the dominant assumptions. And someone from the existing power structure, like the NBER in this case.)
- biehl 11y agoI find it very likely that many "politicians and lazy academics" actually already know it to be false that patents is a cost-effective driver of innovation. However, it is just so darn easy to count patent and claim something like "innovation is rising" or "patent count is falling, we have to hand out more patents so innovation can be seen to rise" etc.
- quadrangle 11y agoThose "many" are still surely the minority. Most people, including academics and politicians, buy the patent propaganda.
- throwawaykf05 11y agoThat is a rather misleading and incomplete TL;DR. The paper actually references a number of other papers from the author (Petra Moser) and presents a number of salient conclusions. Here's one important point: Patents encourage innovation in industries where other methods of maintaining advantage, such as secrecy, are not available. > If patents are important in some industries (such as manufacturing machinery) but not in others (such as scientific instruments or chemicals in the 19th century), changes in patent laws may influence the direction if not the level of technical change (Moser 2005). These patterns are borne out in exhibition data: Countries without patent laws contribute as many exhibits and prize winners as countries with patent law. But their innovations are disproportionately focused on industries in which secrecy is effective, so that inventors are less dependent on patents. Moser 2005 also points out that as the efficacy of reverse engineering increased (today you can reverse engineer almost anything pretty cost-effectively), more exhibitions started to focus on industries with stronger patent protection. This is a curious point, however: it almost suggests that the proportion of innovators in a given population is (was) fixed, and they would innovate where the promise of rewards is highest. Another important point: Cheaper patents meant "democratization of invention". There were more exhibitions with patents from people in rural areas in the US, where patents were cheaper, compared to UK, where patents were more expensive and almost all inventors were based in London. One problem with this paper is that it makes broad generalizations based on narrow data: The fact that plant patents didn't increase the number of new rose varieties registered gets the headline "Intellectual Property Rights for Living Organisms Have Not Encouraged Innovation". It draws conclusions about innovation based on exhibit data where, by the author's own admission (Moser 2005), exhibitions may have significantly discouraged the inclusion of exhibits that were easy to copy. Also, it's important to look through the other cited studies, because they almost always present data that is different from other papers. Some data can be more compelling than others. Nonetheless Moser provides a fascinating view into how innovation may be influenced by incentives and policies.
- jb613 11y ago> "This is a curious point, however: it almost suggests that the proportion of innovators in a given population is (was) fixed, and they would innovate where the promise of rewards is highest." True but I'll add that often for individuals to quit their jobs and focus on innovating requires more than just "the promise of rewards". Immediate funding often trumps the promise - and that funding comes from some kind of investor. Many investors view patents as: 1) a way to recoup at least some their investment dollars if the innovator can't monetize, 2) prevent competitors from simply copying the results of the R&D.
- jb613 11y agoMoser references James Bessen who wrote a highly-cited paper that has been largely debunked [1][2][3]. Specifically, the paper claimed patents cost the economy $29B per year. > "Actually it's good to have someone actually look into the data and challenge the dominant assumptions" Challenging the dominant assumption would be to challenge Bessen's number and the numerous articles that automatically assume that value to be true. [1] http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2117421 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2117421 [2] http://www.iam-media.com/blog/Detail.aspx?g=454c1adc-52c3-4c2d-8981-e4716361f219 http://www.iam-media.com/blog/Detail.aspx?g=454c1adc-52c3-4c... [3] https://gametimeip.wordpress.com/2012/07/30/patent-scholars-challenge-bessen-meurers-bogus-29-b-npe-costs-figure/ https://gametimeip.wordpress.com/2012/07/30/patent-scholars-...
- jacobolus 11y agoI wonder if there have been any attempts to quantify the economic fruits of government-funded research, e.g. by ARPA (especially before being limited to narrowly defense-related projects) or NSF, or research directly undertaken by executive agencies like NASA, etc. Government-sponsored basic research and scholarship often comes under fire from asshole lawmakers claiming to have the interests of “taxpayers” in mind (cf. e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Fleece_Award https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Fleece_Award, or more recently https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/house-bill/3293/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/house-bill/3293...), but as far as I can tell, such research has been one of the primary drivers of “innovation” and economic growth in the US over the past 70+ years.
- dnautics 11y agoThats the fallacy of the seen: You don't know what would have been discovered otherwise. Non-government funded discoveries include salk and Sabin polio vaccines and the chemiosmotic effect.
- dnautics 11y agoI personally notice that a lot of government funded research goes to PIs of questionable intelligence that have merely mastered grantsmanship... How many brilliant young scientists have had their careers cut short by being discouraged by the granting system instead of going on to make discoveries in science?
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoThe grant process is terrible. Let's fix it. Or are you implying that for some unspecified reason that would be impossible?
- dnautics 11y agoIt's impossible. Responsible government has to have a mechanism for accountability, and this is antithetical to basic science.
- quadrangle 11y agoThis seems not to reference one of the strongest and most thorough recent reviews of this whole topic, "The Case Against Patents": https://www.aeaweb.org/articles.php?doi=10.1257/jep.27.1.3 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles.php?doi=10.1257/jep.27.1.3