8 ms·
I had nightmare of a interview experience with AirBnb in 2012. They asked me take 2 days off from work and fly all the way to SFO after I wasted couple of hours
by dominotw 11y ago
I had nightmare of a interview experience with AirBnb in 2012. They asked me take 2 days off from work and fly all the way to SFO after I wasted couple of hours doing their coding homework. The first interviewer started with "your degree is not from a good school" like the very first sentence right to my face. He then asked me a string matching question, and insisted that I code up his brute force solution (with terrible insert complexity) and second interviewer asked me to code up a binary search tree and . After which the recruiter walked in asked me to leave the building saying the interview was not going well and walked me out of the office.
I felt so humiliated, worthless and traumatized that I stopped interviewing for atleast 3 years after that. I now have (irrational) fear of interviews.
This experience has dissuaded many of my friends from applying there.
- doug1001 11y agoit's them that should feel humiliated. It's not like you showed up at their door right off the street; you successfully completed their take-home coding problem and i assume at least one prior telephone interview.
- maxaf 11y agoThat sounds horrible! I have no degree at all, which means that I got exactly where my interviewers are entirely for free. No crushing student loan debt, no heat waste of having to take college classes that have nothing whatsoever to do with my chosen profession. Those who have the audacity to judge a person by their degree deserve to have this advantage flown in their faces, if only implicitly.
- kazinator 11y agoThat's just incredibly rude. My degree's not from a good school? That's nothing; your shirt didn't exactly come off the best dressed mannequin in the Sears window.
- blakeyrat 11y agoI think just asking for a degree (in a computer-related field) is kind of a dumb idea. I don't have a degree, and I'm very successful at my software development job. The best programmer I know has a degree in Psychology; another has a degree in Biology. From my own experience as an interviewer, "has a degree" was absolutely not even a factor when determining who was good and who wasn't.
- spike021 11y agoNowadays, at least for their engineering internships, they have a pre-filled list of top schools to choose from followed by an "other" option (at least when I tried applying a couple years ago). That told me exactly what I needed to know. I'd be instantly rejected because of not going to a "good school".
- justinlardinois 11y agoAt least they tell you instead of taking the applications anyways and then tossing out resumes that don't match. I once came across a job application that had TOP SCHOOLS ONLY emblazoned across the top. Thanks for saving me my time in applying.
- Altaer 11y agoI hope this comment doesn't discourage others. I went to a school not known outside of the southeast (and even sometimes not then) and received interviews with many of the top companies (Google, Microsoft, Intel, Amazon, etc), even when I had to check the "other" option for schools.
- w8rbt 11y agoCurious. What schools are on the list? Would a CS degree from Georgia Tech do? Also curious about VT and NC State. I think all three of those are 'good technical schools'.
- spike021 11y agoHere is the screenshot I took at the time: http://i.imgur.com/FXEHuhc.png http://i.imgur.com/FXEHuhc.png
- niuzeta 11y agoThis is making me think twice about applying to AirBnB, or any one of my friends. I will remember this story.
- chetanahuja 11y agoWhoa... That sounds just terrible. What makes it especially terrible is that they already had you do some coding work before flying you in. Something is utterly, terribly wrong with their process if the coding exercise made them think that you were worth flying in for an interview and then they cut short the interview process because they thought it was going so badly. There are other signs that the tech leadership at airbnb is confused. Witness this almost parody of a video of their devs describing how they worked their way through pretty much every javascript hotness de jour through the years. I honestly thought this was some sort of a parody initially... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMvvb6F8dgk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMvvb6F8dgk
- cpeterso 11y ago> This experience has dissuaded many of my friends from applying there. This should be the lesson for employers: an interview candidate who feels good about their interviewing experience, even if they aren't hired, can refer their qualified friends to your company. The alternative is that they might discourage good candidates from interviewing with your company by warning people on Hacker News about its hiring practices. Also, the candidate might be a good fit for a different position in the future.
- nikanj 11y agoBut they only want the super extreme mutant killer rockstars who would destroy galaxies to work there, so it's ok
- mooreds 11y agoIt's almost like we need a glassdoor for folks who've just interviewed at companies.
- SilasX 11y ago... so, like regular GlassDoor.com. Not sure if you were joking: https://www.glassdoor.com/Interview/Airbnb-Interview-Questions-E391850.htm https://www.glassdoor.com/Interview/Airbnb-Interview-Questio...
- mooreds 11y agoHah. Not joking, didn't know. Thanks for pointing this out.
- bogomipz 11y agoExcept glassdoor is a joke. Have you looked at it lately? Everything behind a sign up wall? Terrible layout and iframes.
- SilasX 11y agoYes, how horrible of them to restrict expensively-gathered content to those who have signed up for free...
- bogomipz 11y agoHow is user generated content "expensively-gathered"? Content comes at exactly no cost to them so yeah it is lame. The data comes from community. Have you looked at the site?
- SilasX 11y agoReally? Setting up the site was free? Architecting the systems scalably was free? Popularizing it was free? Getting people to give their information to it was free? Protecting it from spammers and malicious activity was free? Securing it was free? Usefully organizing the data was free? Protection from lawsuits was free? GlassDoor didn't just put itself together one morning, or a free, open-source one would already exist. Do you also spread the meme about "Viagra was invented by accident", as if all the clinical testing, information dissemnation, regulatory approval, chemical isolation, etc were accidents too?
- kafkaesq 11y ago"Your degree is not from a good school" Next time they do that, I hope the candidate says whatever profanities they feel obliged to say to the interviewer's face. And then walks out. By all means, keep posting + telling your friends about this experience.
- danbolt 11y agoAgreed. This sort of socio-academic elitism really shouldn't be tolerated in the 21st century.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIts all too common. Probably for the usual reason - it works so well. Many candidates from a 'good school' have been filtered for ability, so essentially come with an endorsement. Those from other schools don't have that endorsement. They may be equally capable, but then again they may not. In fact, often not. So, discrimination is rampant because it works so well. Its not fair, possibly not legal, but hard to stamp out.
- kafkaesq 11y agoThey have a perfect right to use educational background as a filter. But that's not the issue here. If that's the filter they want to use -- the time to apply it is before inviting the candidate to take 3 days out of his/her life to fly across the country for an interview. If it's such a huge "ding" for them that a candidate doesn't come from a certain set of preferred schools -- fine, don't invite them for an interview. It's really quite simple. Of it's a "ding", but they want to give the candidate a "shot" -- that's fine too, but there's no need to blatantly neg the candidate right to their face. It serves no purpose; it's just uncivil and unprofessional. (No purpose, that is, other than to give the interviewer an ego rush, and thereby provide a temporary defense of sorts against their own very deeply rooted insecurities. That, and to basically deep-six the candidate's performance, and nullify whatever enthusiasm they might have had for Airbnb during the rest of the, by that point, manifestly pointless "interview"). And the fact that such allegedly highly educated people would so quickly resort to numbskull behavior like this suggests that maybe's it's not such a good filter, after all.
- rcurry 11y ago"The first interviewer started with "your degree is not from a good school" like the very first sentence right to my face." That's just nuts, what a horrible experience.
- hibikir 11y agoOne thing you might not realize is that many companies ask a lot of employees to interview people, and therefore they are not well vetted. If an interviewer is terrible, chances are they don't know! Please, let their recruiting department of things like that. If they are not a terrible company, they'll probably do something about it.
- x0x0 11y agoThat sucks. I was an internal referral there for an ml position. They rolled a fucking front-end developer who had never looked at my resume into my first interview just shy of 25 minutes late. And yes I'm sure about the time, because I was walking out at 25 minutes. Dude was nice and we had fun chatting (not about work, just a cool outdoorsy dude), but we had nothing in common in the work we do. I finally talked to one of their ml people and absolutely nailed that part of the interview. And talked to a weird founder (who always asks weird questions. That were not a good fit for a quantitative person.) They then decided they weren't sure if I wanted to work there (apparently because, you know, I'm in the habit of wasting a day of my life interviewing for giggles) and made me have another conversation with an early engineer there. Who was really cool, but still, it was a strange process. They also low-balled me on cash, and were strange about it when I turned them down and didn't negotiate at all. Someone else offered me $20k more and I figured it was a sign they wanted me so I went with them. The whole thing was a strange experience.
- haylem 11y ago> They then decided they weren't sure if I wanted to work there (apparently because, you know, I'm in the habit of wasting a day of my life interviewing for giggles) That's not really fair though. Tons of people apply for jobs because they need a job. I've surely done it in the past. I've applied and accepted jobs I didn't give a damn crap about. I had to pay rent, feed 2 kids, and pay my wife's tuition. And even did so with multiple jobs at the same time. Anything else was secondary. I went into interviews, praised the greatness of the ideas of some shitty startups which were doomed to fail. I always showed up prepared and was "professional" (in so far as you can show up and not give a rat's ass, but not let it show), and always tried to show I was invested by having already ideas about their products, website, etc... But still, didn't actually care for that stuff. So, I was motivated and a good "employee", but was I a good fit? Probably not. And, on the other hand, I also actually did interview at times just for giggles. Or for practice. Or just in case. Or to get leverage. And when I was the recruiting, while I surely wouldn't assume that the person in front of me would be "interviewing for giggles" (at first), I can totally understand the "weren't sure if I wanted to work there". Like I answered on another part of this thread: the onus / burden of proof is on you, you are the one who has to show you really want to be there (even though you actually may not). It's screwed up, but it's how it is, because we also work for money. I know I did often. Still did my best in any job I got though. (And you should not expect that either, actually. I'm similarly pissed by friends or colleagues who tell me "damn it's like these guys don't care about the job or don't give it all". Well, heck yeah, why would they?)
- solids 11y agoThere is no job in the world that can keep me in the building after hearing that insult.
- bogomipz 11y agoAre you kidding me? This actually happened? I understand maybe feeling traumatized but really fuck those people. Its a shame that Glassdoor is such a pile of garbage there should be more of a forum for people to get the word out about such douchey and unprofessionalism. I hate to generalize but I feel like this bratty and completely unprofessionalism seem to be quite common in San Francisco and the Peninsula. I am basing this on interviews I have had and others I've spoken to. This childish behavior is not really common in other parts of the country - It's hard to imagine this happening in New York, Boston or Austin for instance.
- throwaway_jyhk 11y agoApplied quite a while back for a non-engineering role, just to give other career paths a try. Had to head down to their office 3 times to meet with at least 4 people, after 3 separate Skype interviews. After that, I got a month of silence, which I thought meant silent rejection. Cut to a week later, was having brunch with a friend from another valley startup and said person was telling me a joke that a friend from AirBnb had told during a yacht party limited to only people not from my country. Turns out there was a crappy interviewee from my country who didn't know what was "shared economy", so he decided to reject the guy. Which was fine because maybe it's their company policy or vision. What wasn't fine was said interviewer went on to say "This is why I'll never fucking hire a person from this country." So I asked my friend, "Is this friend of yours XXX?" "Yeah, how'd you know?" "That's my interviewer. I'm that guy you're laughing about." It was an awkward brunch.
- GuiA 11y agoJust to add a data point - I interviewed with AirBnB in January 2014 and had a very similar experience. I was referred by a college classmate and close friend who used to work there at the time, who knows me extremely well, and is easily in the top 1% of engineers I know (Linux contributor, loved by every employer he's ever had, etc.). He told me I totally had the level to work there, and was better than most people he worked with. So I went along with it, and went to their holiday parties, where one of their execs schmoozed with me for a while, told me I sounded like a great fit, and a recruiter would be in touch with me. I talk to the recruiter on the phone, get assigned a home coding challenge. I spend a Saturday on it, and get a perfect score on it. I don't know if it was by design or not, but it showed me the rankings of every person who ever did that challenge. I was tied for 1st place with 40 or so other past candidates, in a pool of a few thousand participants. I do their onsite interviews (fortunately I was local to SF) - don't remember much, except that they felt very stilted. But it was the usual "here's a canned problem I know the best answer to, you have 40 minutes to figure it out while I give out cryptic clues". After 3 or 4 of them, I sit in the room alone for about 30 minutes - the recruiter then comes to me and tells me that they won't move forward, bye bye. My friend met me outside for a smoke, and told me he had no clue what happened. Oh well. AirBnB definitely left a bitter taste in my mouth, but I got a much better gig at a much better company a few months later, so things worked out.
- JeremyMorgan 11y agoThe "good school" thing is an entire topic in itself. You get good and bad from any school, but from what I've found over the years is people want Ivy League or close when they want someone just. like. them. Someone that looks like them, talks like them, thinks like them. They want a person who will be a puppet for management, nothing more. I have worked with, and currently worked with people who are amazing problem solvers and developers who went to community college or trade schools. Recently I worked with one of the smartest people I've ever known who had no college experience at all. He's so good at his job his makes over 6 figures with a high school diploma with no student loan debt.. how could you not call this person smart? I definitely wouldn't say that people who come top schools aren't top talent, but it's no guarantee and I think it's silly when people require it.