3 ms·
> There's no doubt that with further refinement, we'll soon see AI play Go at a level well beyond human Why is there no doubt? I strongly doubt there even exis
by mcv 11y ago
> There's no doubt that with further refinement, we'll soon see AI play Go at a level well beyond human
Why is there no doubt? I strongly doubt there even exists a go level that's well beyond human. There is hypothetical perfect play of course, but there is absolutely no way to guarantee perfect play. And while I have no way to judge, I've heard that 9p players may not be all that far removed from perfect play. One legendary player once boasted that if he had black (no komi, I assume), he would beat God (who of course plays perfect go).
There is of course no way to know if that's true or gross overconfidence, but it's certainly possible that there's not all that much room left beyond the level of 9p players.
AlphaGo will no doubt improve, and reduce the number of slips like his move 79 in the 4th game, but it's never going to be perfect, and there's always the chance that it will miss an unexpected threat.
- baddox 11y agoYou could always argue what "a level well beyond humans" means, but I'd say if a computer can consistently dominate the best human players that would count.
- TwoBit 11y agoGiven the crushing that AlphaGo did, I don't believe your statement about humans having near perfect play.
- goldbrick 11y agoCan you quantify "crushing"?
- eru 11y ago4 - 1.
- mcv 11y agoNot all humans, obviously, but 9p players really are far, far better than other players. And there's another 9p who has won 8 out of 10 matches against Lee Sedol, so there's nothing superhuman about a 4-1 result at that level. I'm really just objecting to the description of this as "beyond human". Yes, it's good, and it's many orders of magnitude beyond my level, but so are Lee Sedol and other 9p players.