4 ms·
I don't know about the OP, but I'd say many objections to "content" is less to do with it describing a web composed of documents and more to do with it describi
by notahacker 11y ago
I don't know about the OP, but I'd say many objections to "content" is less to do with it describing a web composed of documents and more to do with it describing a web composed of documents conceived as a means rather than an end.
"Content" is to a large extend marketing shorthand for "text which improves our conversion funnel or sells CPM slots by being well optimised for search queries and/or social clicks". Which certainly wasn't the intention of the original web either.
Journalists, authors, researchers and people blogging for the joy of blogging generally don't refer to their output as "content", and do think their work is primarily intended to communicate, albeit mostly in one-to-many fashion.
Of course regardless of how idealistic their intentions, most journalists have always produced much of their output for publications whose management teams largely consider it as something to wrap ads around, but that approach is far more pervasive and metrics-driven on the modern web.
- mikeash 11y ago"Content" is to a large extend marketing shorthand for "text which improves our conversion funnel or sells CPM slots by being well optimised for search queries and/or social clicks". I guess that's the disconnect. I see that some people use it that way, but to me it's far more broad than that. I would certainly refer to blogs and other such things as "content" too.
- dangoor 11y agoI also find "content" to be a useful shorthand for things like podcasts and videos which can't be lumped in with "writing".
- adiabatty 11y agoMaybe the most widely-agreed-upon definition of "content" is "others' writing and things they publish". Consider NSBlog, a fantastic blog full of interesting and useful information for programming for OS X and iOS. I don't think of my blog as a content source, but I do think of NSBlog as one. I wonder under what conditions mikeash thinks of his blog as "content" — as far as I remember, the only time I think of my blog/website as content is when I'm looking at the whole thing and thinking "Man, there's not much here. I should write more often." However, when I'm writing something that goes on it, I don't think of myself as "producing content", I think of what I'm doing as _writing_. Maybe people call things "content" only when they're sufficiently removed from the specifics of what is being written/filmed/drawn?
- mikeash 11y agoI never thought of my own blog like that, nor did I think of it not like that, it just never occurred to me. Maybe it's just generality versus specificity. My blog has "programming articles," your blog has "writing," blogs in general have "content" (they might have images or video or who knows what). And just like you wouldn't say "objects" when you could say "people," maybe I wouldn't say "content" when I could say "articles." And now these words have lost whatever little meaning they had to me!
- rpdillon 11y agoCory Doctorow published an book called "Content". I'd never thought of it until he wrote it, but the idea of 'content' does suggest the presence of a container. http://craphound.com/content/Cory_Doctorow_-_Content.html#1 http://craphound.com/content/Cory_Doctorow_-_Content.html#1