2 ms·
If Lavabit refused, some random scapegoat within Lavabit (like, say the CEO, or whoever is deemed as the scapegoat) might get arrested, Lavabit would probably b
by dheera 11y ago
If Lavabit refused, some random scapegoat within Lavabit (like, say the CEO, or whoever is deemed as the scapegoat) might get arrested, Lavabit would probably be ordered to close, and our lives wouldn't be affected too much. They're a tiny startup. They can be bullied quite easily without affecting national peace.
If Apple were ordered to close in an instant, there would be mass upheaval, unrest, protests, and huge economic losses just because of the sheer number of people that depend on their products on a daily basis for mission-critical things. Violence would break out. We might even end up facing nothing short of a civil war, and the federal government probably wouldn't want to risk that.
- spaceheeder 11y agoThe argument that Apple is too-big-to-compel is in the same spirit as arguing that they're too-rich-to-compel. So my closing question stands: if Apple prevails, how likely are courts to treat this as a precedent if and when the government goes after a small fry again?
- ogsharkman 11y agoI'm not sure if it's a matter of precedent for the small frys. By that I mean, even if there is precedent you still need a tremendous amount of money/legal power to fight.
- oddevan 11y agoI would think so. My understanding of the Lavabit case was that it was upheld on procedural grounds and thus not precedent-setting. Apple has the money and the will to fight this so that it is precedent-setting* and thus usable by the not-as-expensive lawyer protecting the next Lavabit. * By which I mean I could see Apple purposefully fighting this to the Supreme Court, even if it means "appealing" a case they've already won so that it goes to a higher court.