5 ms·
The moment you mention "child pornography" as justification I consider that you have lost the argument. This is simply Godwin's Law for the modern era.
by bsder 11y ago
The moment you mention "child pornography" as justification I consider that you have lost the argument.
This is simply Godwin's Law for the modern era.
- SturgeonsLaw 11y agoLovejoy's Law - "would somebody please think of the children"
- Silhouette 11y agoIt's also a horribly counter-productive argument. This is obviously a politically charged subject, but let's try to be rational for a moment. It seems likely that by far the most prolific creators of child pornography today are... children. What today's parent and grandparent generations used to do in relative privacy behind the metaphorical bike shed, surely today's teenagers are doing with their phones and laptops, perhaps unaware of how insecure and non-private their communications might be. There are all sorts of difficult ethical questions about how that kind of behaviour should in itself be treated in law, but let's ignore those for now. In any case, if kids are carrying around that kind of material or sending it to each other, surely the best way to protect them is to make sure it stays as private as it should be? That means making everything as secure and safely encrypted as possible. Arguing for weaknesses in encryption or creating backdoor vulnerabilities has exactly the opposite effect.
- TACIXAT 11y agoWhile I agree that privacy and secure communications are the best means to protect kids in the first world, there are still enough horrible people in the world who rape children and take pictures, as well, there is child sex trafficking. We shouldn't forget that these things exist and reduce child porn to snapchat and selfies.
- fl0wenol 11y agoThe availability of strong encryption does not enable or disable child rape or human trafficking. This will happen behind traditional closed doors and guarded with guns and/or money unless other aspects of society and human nature change.
- Silhouette 11y agoWe shouldn't forget that these things exist and reduce child porn to snapchat and selfies. No, of course we shouldn't. There really are bad people in the world, and some of them really do do very evil things, and there really are good reasons to have police and security services, and they really do need reasonable powers to enable them to do their jobs and deal with the bad people. But what we should do is keep these things in perspective and ideally set public policy based on evidence and rational arguments. Creating security loopholes that might help the authorities to find and stop a small number of genuinely evil people but might also create millions of new vulnerabilities to be targeted by other evil people (or even the same ones) isn't necessarily a good trade-off.
- EdHominem 11y ago> there are still enough horrible people in the world who [emotion instead of substance] What's the evidence that we need [abusive bill of the day] to fix that? Why do we think the potential harm averted is greater than the harm we know comes from overreaching laws and abusive governments? Human trafficking at all, sex or otherwise, is horrible, common, and relatively easily stopped without new laws - at least for the victims of the moment - so go spend time and effort helping rather than beating the panic drum as you are now.
- TACIXAT 11y agoI think you're reading a little more into my comment than was there. I didn't agree with what the parent comment said about child porn. I'm very much in favor of secure communication channels and privacy.
- tzs 11y agoIn a society where most followed your approach, would there be any point in child pornography even being illegal?
- zanny 11y agoThe creation of it certainly remains illegal, and its existence is a violation of individuals right to privacy (these images are never taken with consent, because the victims cannot consent). In the same way you could consider it a violation of your privacy for someone you do not want there taking your picture in private, child porn violates the same principle. So child porn can be perfectly illegal without having an explicit law saying "Child Porn is illegal". Its creation violates so many fundamentals and its distribution violates a subset of those. But the reason for the illegality is as important as the legality in the first place. Some of the most horrible nations commit acts we deem moral in consequence but often do them for still vile reasons (ie, you don't execute the mafia boss for rampant murder and robbery, but because hes threatening your own power).
- neutronicus 11y agoWhy is that? If certain tales of the dark net are to be believed, it has enabled an unprecedented level of communication between abusers of children. Seems like an obvious "con" of widely-available secure communication. If you believe the "pros" outweigh it, say so, but don't pretend it isn't relevant.
- sbov 11y agoBecause it's usually used to emotionally manipulate people. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children
- bsder 11y agoBecause it is an argument that people fall back on when rational arguments are failing. In addition, the "child pornography" that people want to use as justification is REALLY RARE. The biggest kiddie porn bust in the history of the US was Operation Delego which had 600 members worldwide. Most of whom were busted with good, old fashioned police work. Now, let's talk about the common "child pornography"--Suzie has naked selfies on her phone. Do you really think that Johnny won't go to a dodgy Chinese site to get the iPhone crack to let him see those? Relevant Dilbert: http://dilbert.com/strip/1996-01-24 http://dilbert.com/strip/1996-01-24
- EdHominem 11y agoBecause the story is essentially a lie. The numbers, and the financial complicity, and the crypto-capabilities. There's no pedo-mafia. Also that and there are so many more successful ways to catch molestation that we aren't taking. It's not that molestation and exploitation isn't bad, but when you see someone ranting about it you can be pretty sure they're just doing it to push a political goal. It's an obvious call for censorship and more agency funding. If the list of relevant things could only be five-thousand items long, this wouldn't even be on it. And then we get to the cons, many of which are potentially Orwellian.