I was gong to comment "Did you skip the part about doing the work of trying to scientifically reproduce the results with the same data?" after down-voting. I r

I was gong to comment "Did you skip the part about doing the work of trying to scientifically reproduce the results with the same data?" after down-voting. I read your username after the vote. I would take it back, if I could, since it's your right to either be modest on the matter or if you really feel that all you did was "send them a friendly email". My apologies; I felt I owe an explanation since I was likely the first vote.