4 ms·
No, you back off on backdoors
- junto 11y agoThis very much mirrors my sentiments. Not only is the proverbial cat out of the bag, but it's proudly parading around with its tail in the air, frequently spraying on all the furniture. And if anyone has a cat, you'll know that you just can't stop them from doing it by force or coercion. You need to remove all the furniture or remove the cat.
- Qwertious 11y agoIs the cat meant to be the government, or is it meant to be the programmers?
- junto 11y agoThe cat was supposed to be encryption in the wild. The furniture is the public. The government can't easily take encryption away. They can ban it is the US, but there are plenty of alternative countries that won't follow suit, and can then benefit from US tech being kicked in the teeth by its own government.
- DannyBee 11y agoMeh. Eventually tech companies decide they like money and not being in jail more than they like fighting for people's rights, and they throw up their hands and say "what are we gonna do, it's the law", and do it. See: Every other time this has happened.
- majke 11y agoWell, we did win first crypto wars, didn't we? Sure, the war was long, there were casualties.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 11y agoWhat casualties are you referring to?
- SturgeonsLaw 11y agoI'm not a tech company, and I'm not an American citizen, so US law has no influence over me. I'd build an end-to-end crypto communications system out of spite, in reaction to these laws, and I'm not particularly activist - and who knows how many other people there are like me out there. Don't give up. Adopting a defeatist attitude does nothing but help the enemy.
- marssaxman 11y agoWell, no, not really. Use of encryption is growing because the things people want to do with their computers and networks can't be done safely without it. Governments could certainly abuse their powers by forbidding encryption, but they would necessarily make all their subjects' computers and networks less valuable in the process. There is thus a strong financial incentive for tech companies to resist bad encryption policy: their ability to grow is limited by the potential utility of their products.
- shkkmo 11y ago> "What will happen is, if everybody goes to their respective corners, and the tech community says ‘either we have strong perfect encryption or else it's Big Brother and an Orwellian world', what you'll find is that after something really bad happens, the politics of this will swing and it will become sloppy and rushed and it will go through Congress in ways that are dangerous and not thought through," Does Obama get that the only way to stamp out strong encryption IS an Orwellian world? Anything else is just harming the security of your citizens and the competitiveness of your tech companies.
- citizensixteen 11y ago>If you succeed in achieving your nightmare Orwellian scenario, I promise you this: I'll emigrate to an extradition-free country. It appears as if we have already succeeded at creating this Orwellian scenario and seems as if Huxley was correct and we are currently amusing ourselves to death. The truth is being drowned out by and infinite amounts of triviality and the masses are begging for more. This Orwellian world has no boundaries and there is no escape to some Utopian country. For better or worse this is the world we have created and we need to realize that is not a situation that will be solved by leaving the country. Crypto is going to be a Forever War. Perhaps it will be more effective if we take the long view. Huxley vs Orwell http://highexistence.com/amusing-ourselves-to-death-huxley-vs-orwell/ http://highexistence.com/amusing-ourselves-to-death-huxley-v...
- nickik 11y agoOutside of the people that are primed to be Alphas, Betas or something Huxleys world was not actually that bad. Their is no logical incapablity that people can not live in a consumer society and lose all other, including social, values. Its always temting for intellectuals to point to Huxley and rant on the evils of consumersim. They simple have different preferences then most other people and are unhappy about it, not that different from your standard christian.