5 ms·
It's a little difficult to pin down the numbers right now because everything has changed so much in the last year. But 95% vs 400% is definately utter nonsense.
by fauigerzigerk 17y ago
It's a little difficult to pin down the numbers right now because everything has changed so much in the last year. But 95% vs 400% is definately utter nonsense.
This IMF paper (http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/spn/2009/spn0925.pdf http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/spn/2009/spn0925.pdf page 35) from Nov 2009 projects US and UK government dept for 2010 to be 94% and 82% of GDP respectively.
The US and the UK, in spite of the many differences, have one important thing in common. In both cases debt is almost exclusively denominated in domestic currency. So neither of the two can default outright as long as there is enough energy left to start the printing presses. Any default would come in the shape of inflation.
- BearOfNH 17y agoas long as there is enough energy left to start the printing presses Intuitively this makes sense but in reality it is not practical. As soon as investors hear the presses crank up (metaphorically speaking) they can predict what's coming and will dump all their US debt, driving up interest rates and forcing a deep[-er] US recession. Politics will then correct this before the USA becomes Northern Zimbabwe.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoI'm not worried about the US becoming Zimbabwe at all (northern or otherwise). But under extreme circumstances, when the alternatives are to default outright or to inflate the debt away, the latter will always be preferrable for a country indebted in its own currency. It's not an option for other countries, so I think it's a useful distinction in spite of the issues you correctly point out.
- btilly 17y agoAfter you figure out the difference between total debt and government debt, you can look for my other comments that show that the quoted 400% figure is indeed reasonable.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoThe figures are apples and oranges. I have no doubt that you can get to a reasonable number of 400% for some form of debt. But if you do that you need to do something similar for all countries you compare.
- btilly 17y agoWhat makes you think that people don't do something similar for other countries? I don't have direct access to the necessary statistics, but based on the figures at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_external_debt http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_external_d... and guessing that most of Greece's debt is externally held, it is looks like Greece's total debt load should be somewhere in the 50-60% range. That looks a lot better than 400%. And fits perfectly with the article's contention that the Greek government has a debt problem, but the rest of Greece does not.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoThe list you point to includes only external debt and combines private and public debt. What that says is simply that US and Japanese citizens borrow at home whilst many others borrow abroad. It's a reflection of the size of a country's debt market and says absolutely nothing about the likelyhood of a government defaulting on its debt.
- btilly 17y agoThe list I pointed to is simply the first thing I came across that could be used to estimate the total indebtedness of Greece. You are right that it is not a direct measurement of total debt. You are also right that total debt is not a direct measurement of government debt risks. However one thing that total debt is good for is seeing how much total weight the economy as a whole is carrying from accumulated debt. From the point of view of the economy it doesn't matter that much who holds the debt. After all money lost to interest is lost just as much whether it is an individual paying direct interest payments or the government raising taxes to pay its interest payments. And besides, debt can quickly change categories. For instance in a credit crisis private debt can suddenly become public debt instead. (In a recent PIMCO article Bill Gross pointed out that in credit crises over the last 300 years that public debt tends to approximately double.) By any comparison with history or other countries, a 400% debt to GNP ratio is very high. It might not spell automatic disaster, but it suggests some rocky times ahead.