4 ms·
Yeah, this is incredibly old news. We already know this. When are they going to investigate why or come up with a new hypothesis? My hypothesis: Most women rej
by Mz 11y ago
Yeah, this is incredibly old news. We already know this. When are they going to investigate why or come up with a new hypothesis?
My hypothesis: Most women reject short men as mates and most men reject fat women as mates. A successful marriage tends to strongly correlate to socioeconomic success, longevity, etc.
- guard-of-terra 11y ago"Most women reject short men as mates" Are you sure? Because this, why being `obvious' after 15 seconds of thinking, may be or not be true. My anecdotal observations reveal an unusual number of pairs where a tall woman happily dates below average height man. It works the other way too, short women often date tall men. Anyway, no person really need most people of opposite genre accepting them as a mate. A few is usually enough. If you'll prove that tall men have more successful marriages, it would be a huge deal, so I assume that no such correlation exist. Successful marriage is a complicated thing and I assume that its relation to ease of dating and partner selectivity is very non-linear.
- Mz 11y agoThis is pretty well established. Most women, even quite short women, want taller men. My ex husband was slightly shorter than me, so it isn't all women. But, yes, bias by women against short men is a well known thing. If they will not even accept a first date because of your height, the odds of marriage go down pretty seriously. You need to get your foot in the door and get to the altar as some minimum prerequisites for achieving a successful marriage.
- colmvp 11y agoOnline dating stats, at least from OKTrends, show tall men have more sexual partners than men below the average height. I also wouldn't be surprised if that also holds true for receiving more responses compared to short men. Furthermore, my recorded stats of women's profiles in the online dating site Match.com show a significantly higher number of women prefer to date men of their own height or taller than women who are willing to date men shorter than them. Plus, it's also not uncommon for short women to exclusively date tall men, whereas it's very rare for even tall women to date guys who are significantly shorter than them.
- guard-of-terra 11y ago"it's very rare for even tall women to date guys who are significantly shorter than them" It's not very relevant who people date, much more relevant who they end up with. Might be counter-intuitive.
- magicGLASSman 11y agoCome on, you normally end up with someone that you date... don't see many people ending up with someone they never dated.
- prawn 11y ago"My anecdotal observations reveal an unusual number of pairs where a tall woman happily dates above average height man. It works the other way too, short women often date tall men." Aren't you saying the same thing as Mz? That women will favour men taller than themselves? A tall woman will often be shorter than an above-average-height man.
- guard-of-terra 11y agoFixed above -> below, sorry for confusion.
- Spooky23 11y agoTall women get screwed in other ways -- guys tend to be intimidated by them, and the more assholely among us will consider them "fat". In my unscientific observation, tall woman / short dude is usually linked to a relatively older woman.
- mobilefriendly 11y agoHeight strongly signals healthy genes, longevity, and access to good nutrition... stands to reason that women would evolve to select for height when choosing a mate.
- Mz 11y agoI am aware of that piece of it. But I think it is more complicated than that and this is probably not the right place to discuss it in earnest. I post as openly female on HN. I am vastly outnumbered by men. Given that situation, some topics are just a great way to get down voted to hell over.
- mobilefriendly 11y agoDefinitely glad you're on HN, hopefully nothing in this conversation is unsettling. I agree, from my experienced male perspective, female desire is way more complicated than just height...a man's confidence, masculinity, fitness, style, and social/business standing are all just as important in the mix. Which is why a short man should not despair but improve the things he can control.
- Mz 11y agoThanks. I hate feeling like some of my comments get downvoted into the negatives merely for providing a female perspective. But, apparently, that bothers me less than the idea of not providing a female perspective at all. Over time, things have gotten better. I like to think that is partly my doing.:-) Take care.