3 ms·
> That is going to pose real problems for the kinds of law enforcement cases that everyone cares about. Those problems have existing solutions: Place a room bu
by Zigurd 11y ago
> That is going to pose real problems for the kinds of law enforcement cases that everyone cares about.
Those problems have existing solutions: Place a room bug where the evildoers meet. Use real-world physical surveillance. Track their movements.
The only thing you can't do with existing solutions is to scale them up to pushbutton mass-surveillance numbers. And that's only a problem if you want to use surveillance as a tool to suppress political/social movements, and our beneficent government would never do that.
- tptacek 11y agoI agree with you. That's something that frustrates me about the "Going Dark" debate. Crypto can pose real problems for justice and safety, and the answer still probably isn't to suppress crypto. Maybe we should just do a better job of funding investigatory work?
- Zigurd 11y ago> Maybe we should just do a better job of funding investigatory work? Many of these supposed problems are a product of "searching under the street lamp." Once you shut off the mass-surveillance street lamp, we may find that the quality of law enforcement rises if only because somebody might get off the internet and look at the backlog of burglary and strong-arm robbery cases.
- tptacek 11y agoThat's almost certainly true. Electronic surveillance has made it easier for investigators to "cheat" their way through a case. But we fund investigations based on how long it takes an investigator to clear a case, so if we make it much harder to do that, something else will have to give.
- mindslight 11y ago> Crypto can pose real problems for justice and safety Exactly like the worries of "shouting fire in a crowded theater". If communication leads to an action that has real world consequences, then criminalize and investigate the actual action. Don't take the lazy way and attempt to police communication.
- tptacek 11y agoI'm sorry, but I don't understand how this sentiment is responsive to anything I wrote.
- mindslight 11y ago"Safety and justice" are abstract concepts. Referencing them without discussing specific situations can only lead one to the conclusion that more is better. I brought things closer to specifics, while needing to stay general, by asserting that any real crime must have real-world physical involvement, which can always be investigated and policed. It's always been possible to execute the "perfect murder", although few manage to accomplish it. I don't see how that could possibly change with the addition of bicycles for the mind, unless they lead to psionic powers. What we're actually "debating" here is law enforcement getting a temporary boost due to criminals' misunderstanding of technology, and now fighting tooth and nail to hold onto the transient. Nobody was breaking out of jail and then posting about it on facialbook in 1950, so in 2050 when someone breaks out of jail and posts on e2e socialnet, police will simply have to use the same classic investigative techniques they've always had.