5 ms·
I've never understood this American thing of giving weight to the opinions of comedians on important matters.
by gadders 11y ago
I've never understood this American thing of giving weight to the opinions of comedians on important matters.
- _neil 11y agoI could be wrong but I don't think this was really a thing until Jon Stewart. And some would point to him going on Crossfire (a 'real' news show) and destroying their hosts as a turning point in his being a credible voice.
- mfoy_ 11y agoIt's because comedians tell jokes, but the mainstream media is a joke.
- krapp 11y agoIt's funny because people refuse to allow themselves to be brainwashed by mainstream news, so they allow themselves to be brainwashed by mainstream entertainment.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoMedieval royals used to employ a court jester for amusement and to fill the unique role of being the only class of people allowed to criticize the nobility, provided of course, it was all said "in jest." "This American thing" had to come from somewhere.
- kzhahou 11y agoMel Brooks coined "stand-up philosophers."
- qihqi 11y agoUsually it's not just the view of the comedians, but the collective view of the writers behind the show. Talk shows are a weird phenomena that exist only in few countries (to not say just US), but they do raise awareness on important issues for their audience (which are people what wouldn't care about that issue by themselves).
- trequartista 11y agoParody and satire has long been one of the most important tools to address and highlight the most important issues of the day.
- coherentpony 11y agoBecause giving weight to the opinions of politicians has proven to be naïve.
- mordocai 11y agoA lot of American comedians are more truthful and balanced about their news reporting than the American news media.
- krapp 11y agoIt's worth keeping in mind, however, that the goal of satirists like John Oliver isn't necessarily to communicate truth, or to be fair, but to lead the viewer to accept one specific, and hopefully humorous, interpretation of the narrative they present. Truth and balance are often at cross-purposes to effective comedy.
- jkmcf 11y agoMy takeaway has been that Stewart, Oliver, and others are humorously pointing out hypocrisy and trying to get people to question the completely one sided, superficial portrayals of the mainstream media. Stewart would go after CNN just as much as Fox, though perhaps for different reasons...
- krapp 11y agoThe media, at least, has a standard to fail to meet when it falls prey to bias, becomes a mouthpiece for the government, or panders to sponsors or corporate interests. Even if Stewart, Oliver, etc. do call out the media, government, and corporations for their hypocrisy (and they deserve to be called out) they have no standards to meet other than to be funny. They have no incentive to be honest or fair about what they do - arguably, their incentive is to be dishonest and biased if doing so meets the expectations of their audience.
- mason240 11y agoIt's a loophole that pundits use to avoid criticism. They can opine and bloviate, and then when called out on inaccuracies their fans will spam you with responses of "just a comedian" or "it's satire bro" (as if being satire absolves you from criticism). You've already received a dozen such responses, so it clearly works for them.
- maxerickson 11y agoYou've already received a dozen such responses, so it clearly works for them. The pointing out inaccuracies predicate is missing from the process here.
- mfoy_ 11y agoJon Oliver lies to me about Geography on a regular basis, and I'm ashamed to admit I only catch it once every so often...
- sp332 11y agoYou don't have to. The video includes statements from the involved parties so you can see what their arguments really are.
- fmihaila 11y agoYou seem to imply "real" journalism cannot use humour, because somehow the goal of getting laughs crowds out the primary goal of informing the audience. And yet studies show that Stewart's audiences, as an example, are better informed than those who take their news primarily from network news channels. Inferring "it's comedy, therefore not serious/credible" is a fallacy, just as "news read by serious anchor is balanced and informative" is a fallacy. People should stop judging books by their cover and shows by the blurbs on their websites. Ask instead whether the content is factual or not. By this standard, Last Week Tonight is very credible. I often say that John Oliver isn't trying to make you laugh, but to make you cry. He uses comedy to penetrate the audience's guard in order to deliver the painful truth.
- Arnt 11y agoA few years ago in Italyy, Berlusconi gained effective power most/all TV stations and major newspapers. Not very much later, publication and sales of books about current affairs started growing. The internet interprets censorship as damage and routes around it, as the famous quotation says. Much the same applies to civic society, IMNSHO. EDIT: ... which doesn't imply that either side necessarily wins. Sigh.
- dspillett 11y agoYou are thinking about it the wrong way. No, it isn't good that comedians are the only way some people consume news; and nor is it good that sometimes they are the only way certain opposing (but sometimes provably correct) views are aired. But the situation says more about the partisan and incompletely researched/verified (often completely not researched and/or verified!) reporting generally output by the other media outlets, than it does about the satire shows and their audience. That isn't just bad, it is terrible and probably quite damaging. Of course the satire outlets are themselves often partisan, or at very least subconsciously biased, but they do tend to be more honest about that. And it isn't just in the US: the same is true (to a lesser but growing extent) in the UK and other parts of Europe.
- oldmanjay 11y agoDid you have a follow up? I assure you, professing ignorance of American culture isn't a very interesting thing, certainly not enough to stand alone as a comment.
- gadders 11y agoA fair point. It's not all Americans. I would say as a Brit, though, there isn't really an equivalent comedian here that would help inform popular opinion in the same way. Russell Brand tried but I don't think he ever had the same impact.
- dspillett 11y agoIndividual comedians no, but shows like The News Quiz, HIGNFY, Mock The Week, and so forth perform a similar act.
- jaegerpicker 11y agoYou have seen our politicians right? You hope that at least a comedian is funny. Also it's hardly an "American thing" nearly every country in the world engages in satire in some form.