7 ms·
Most Americans Say Government Doesn’t Do Enough to Help Middle Class
- gedy 11y agoAssuming that starting and owning small businesses are the backbone for a strong middle class, then yes the gov't doesn't "help" enough. But instead of actively helping, maybe it would be better phrased as not passively hurting. The left rallies around regulation and benefits that frequently require or assume big business, and right's "pro-business" stance is also focused on big corporations, free trade, etc. Have some family members running "Mom and Pop" sized businesses and it's very tough for them to make a living.
- yolesaber 11y agoIn my experience (have some family members running small businesses as well, including my father) the crunch seems to be coming from the fact that the middle class has just enough money to make mortgage / car payments - which keep them in the middle class - but not enough left over to spend at small businesses. If compensation was rising in accordance, there wouldn't be a problem. However large corporations are hoarding cash like crazy and leaving employees out in the cold which in turn harms small businesses.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoThis is why campaign finance is the #1 problem facing American democracy today. It's not about the election, it's the re-election. It's about the sausage-making. Even if you come to Washington without the support of wealthy donors, you will have to work with people who do. Representatives in the pockets of special interests will favor them because those are the groups that truly hold politicians accountable, because losing re-election is akin to flushing a political career down the toilet. So policy tends to favor the special interests, even when the popular majority opposes it. I do not believe it is possible for a powerful state like America to avoid corruption, because high concentrations of power insulate themselves from accountability (which is a threat to power like any other), and it takes immense power to reap immense benefits (whether those benefits reach the general population or are at the expense of others is a different story, like the CIA-backed coup in 1950s Guatemala which broke the back of local communists/socialists and ensured greater profits for United Fruit Company and lower costs to American consumers). Therefore, I advocate a citizen's veto amendment, allowing the public to reject laws passed by representatives who only give a damn about the constituents during election season. If corporations and wealthy individuals are going to control Congress and the Executive, the people ought to retain the right to say no.
- norea-armozel 11y ago"Therefore, I advocate a citizen's veto amendment, allowing the public to reject laws passed by representatives who only give a damn about the constituents during election season." What happens when corporations give goodies to the citizens and shape the message in the social media in such a way that it makes feigned outrage seem organic that the common person votes their way? Don't think you can change reform the system which the powers that be created. It's their game where you just happen to be one of the tiny pieces in it. The real problem is that no one dares to think that maybe it's time to stop playing their game once and for all. That thought is too scary for most.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoAnd how would you stop playing their game? Industrial scale propaganda has been as much a part of our environment since the early 20th century as atmospheric lead pollution. We have to work with it because we can't ignore it. Also, I believe that private corporations should pay for public goods (free to the public) as a means to attract talented employees who can increase profits, so I am not convinced by your argument or solution, if there is one at all.
- norea-armozel 11y agoThere's far too many assumptions laid in your arguments thus far to unpack them without writing volumes on this problem. But I'll sum it up this way with a question: do you think you should work to justify your existence? If you say yes to this question then you're in their trap, thus any solution you propose on the predicate of everyone has to work is flawed from the get go. If you say no, then you got a starting point to build out from the old social/economic order, so branch out and explore that thought some more.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoIf I say yes (that my life requires work to be fully justified) you will disregard my agency as being a part of a "trap." If I say no then I suspect you will again fail to provide concrete examples to match your rhetoric, because frankly I haven't a clue what point you are trying to make. Everyone should have a function, at least. House-spouses who run errands and raise children are just as much a worker as the breadwinner, for example. But some people will fall through the cracks and we shouldn't worry about managing everybody unless they place an undue burden on society. If you have anything specific to say, say it. Otherwise, we should probably get back to work.
- tanker 11y ago"Overall, 62% say the government doesn’t do enough to help the middle class, while 29% say it does about the right amount and 6% say it does too much. Roughly the same share (59%) says the government does not do enough for poor people or for children (59% each), and 66% say the government doesn’t do enough to help older people." Basically, people think the government doesn't do enough. I would like to see views on taxes included in the same survey.