4 ms·
If I were told "Here's several million dollars, an Answers platform, and a mandate to make a super-scalar return", I would immediately start trying to pull off
by patio11 17y ago
If I were told "Here's several million dollars, an Answers platform, and a mandate to make a super-scalar return", I would immediately start trying to pull off Demand Media, starting each property with a core of content produced by cheap freelancers and then thickening them out with real UGC as they gained traction in the search engines. The million get spent on the freelancers and on having my crack team of engineers build a search prediction algorithm so that I know, e.g., what the top three questions about birdfeeders and the highest payout topics are.
The resulting company looks very, very different than what StackOverflow looks like... but it would make sense, I guess. (Major risk of getting annihilated by Google in the next 12 months but, hey, not my money.)
I generally yield to no one in my agreement against "land grab" economics. However, this space actually is a land grab. Maybe it isn't obvious to DHH because DHH doesn't really need to worry about the nuts and bolts of SEO all that much, but Demand Media can create a page for $15 and sell $40 of ads on it this year (it will still be there next year). That model scales to the effing moon, at least until Google gives them the smackdown.
- replicatorblog 17y agoThis is the key to it. Technology development isn't the point of an investment in a company like this (though some new tech will be needed and created). You need to find editors, create partnerships, advertise (as dirty a word as that may be) and provide runway to iterate. A question site on graphic design might be different than one on cooking and even more different from one on the finer points of SQL. I do think the land grab comparison is fair. If you can get into the verticals quickly and establish a lead in content it is that much harder for the next guy. I like 37S, but I don't get the compulsive need to criticize anyone that takes funding or sells their company as a sell out.
- vaksel 17y agothere is a difference between Demand Media and StackExchange...howto sites get linked to, Q&A sites do not. eHow is a PR8 site, while SO is a PR6 site. Original content will always outrank Q&A. I covered it here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1128146 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1128146
- keltex 17y agoI think the one thing that SO is missing is one of their claimed features, being a "community wiki". If they could somehow leverage that content in more of an article format then they could have that "article site" aspect. Right now they just look Q&A.
- blasdel 17y agoThat post was deleted, linking to this I presume: http://blog.styleguidance.com/post/391922539/stackoverflow-getting-vc-funding-is-a-recipe-for http://blog.styleguidance.com/post/391922539/stackoverflow-g...
- vaksel 17y agoyes that was it. Apparently my blog got permabanned on HN for outing that Techcrunch intern.
- astrec 17y agoReally? Although I found it to be in very poor taste it was on your own blog and I'd be surprised and disappointed if this was the case. Any moderators willing to confirm or deny?
- vaksel 17y agoit was submitted to HN too(made the front page)...got an email from pg for it...called me an asshole and said that he was embarrassed that such meanness was posted on HN
- plinkplonk 17y ago"got an email from pg for it...called me an asshole and said that he was embarrassed that such meanness was posted on HN" Good on you, PG!
- astrec 17y agoIt wasn't exactly your finest hour. That said, I (perhaps naively) assume that the HN community is strong enough to self heal sans permaban - the intent of flag, innit?