3 ms·
"the public will be putting their data within reach of every hacker in the world through a government-imposed weakness" You're reusing arguments about key escr
by skybrian 11y ago
"the public will be putting their data within reach of every hacker in the world through a government-imposed weakness"
You're reusing arguments about key escrow in a way that doesn't apply.
This isn't key escrow. It's about software updates, which use digital signing in the way it's supposed to be used.
Apple's software updates are guarded by a private key. Of course they need to keep the private key safe, but sometimes use it to sign releases. It's expensive but doable, and a good thing too, because the entire app ecosystem (not to mention https and Bitcoin) depends on keeping private keys safe.
If keeping a private key safe is impossible even for a well-funded company like Apple, public key encryption doesn't work. Game over.
- studentrob 11y ago> If keeping a private key safe is impossible even for a well-funded company like Apple, public key encryption doesn't work. Game over. Funny, FBI Director James Comey says the same thing [1] And, the DOJ has suggested that if Apple does create the requested tool, then they can just give the source code and key to the FBI [2] I think we know where you stand on this issue. [1] https://youtu.be/g1GgnbN9oNw?t=2h43m12s https://youtu.be/g1GgnbN9oNw?t=2h43m12s [2] http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/mar/11/fbi-could-force-apple-to-hand-over-private-key http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/mar/11/fbi-could-...
- skybrian 11y agoDo you? Actually I'm strongly against anyone having to turn over a private key to the government.
- cyphar 11y ago> If keeping a private key safe is impossible even for a well-funded company like Apple, public key encryption doesn't work. Game over. The fact that only Apple has to sign updates (there's no user key to sign updates as well) and the user can't change the key is an issue as well.