5 ms·
I have written about this before and, in a nutshell, there are problems inherent in cutting everyone a check. If you literally give everyone a check starting fr
by Mz 11y ago
I have written about this before and, in a nutshell, there are problems inherent in cutting everyone a check. If you literally give everyone a check starting from birth, you will almost certainly see poor women cranking out babies to increase their own income and they will not be good mothers and they will not raise children who are decent human beings, prepared to contribute to the world.
One of my previous blog posts about my objections too ubi:
http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2015/09/it-was-obsolete-before-we-opened.html http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2015/09/it-was-obsol...
- derefr 11y agoI agree that there are problems if we just add UBI on top of the current system. But that doesn't go against my point—we can set up a mechanism (give everyone money) and then write policy assuming that mechanism (e.g. pass laws about children's income requiring it to go into trusts, where any money being spent by the parents requires a new Financial Auditing branch of Child Protective Services to do a check that the money is being spent for the child's best interests.) The important thing is that the latter step is general: it safeguards the interests of children who get any kind of income, including child actors, child competitive-tournament winners, etc. If this were just part of the decision process of granting the money as income in the first place, then these side-benefits would be left unrealized. It's the same as the mechanism/policy separation of Internet infrastructure: instead of trying to create a physical-layer transport with perfect reliability, we create a simple physical-layer transport (Ethernet) and then reliability is a policy decision made at a higher level, compensating for a physical layer where "potential unreliability" is taken as axiomatic. We should strive for "foundational" laws that set up universal systems of incentives—because that lets us predict how society will shift in aggregate. Then, having done so, we should be able to write specific, ephemeral laws that assume such incentives exist, and then create multiplicative or countervailing forces to shift those incentives for the specific case. The one obvious example of where the law does this is in terms of inalienable rights. The constitution "grants" them universally (though the language is more like "these rights are already axiomatic in the cultural fabric, and we're just making them explicit in law so they can be pointed at.") Then, legislation and caselaw just work in terms of them, layering new things above and around them to achieve an effect, rather than being able to say anything like "and in this case, [some right] doesn't apply." For any given area of policy, having a low-level non-changeable core policy that can always be trusted to be true—and then a high-level set of situational laws to attenuate the output of that core, rather than overriding it—is both easier to legislate, easier to adjudicate, easier to enforce, and easier to learn. Everyone including later policy-makers can know and rely on the core policy always applying, so they don't have to worry; there's no combinatoric explosion of "if we add this, then will that other thing that was intended to be countervailing now go too far when this branch of the core decision tree is taken?" Instead, we just get the equivalent of D&D's "non-stackable bonuses": an explicit notion of a "non-core law" (like a notion of a "bonus") where the core law can set meta-policy on how policies combine.
- dllthomas 11y ago> where any money being spent by the parents requires a new Financial Auditing branch of Child Protective Services to do a check that the money is being spent for the child's best interests. Yikes
- derefr 11y agoMind you, the default assumption would be that the money does just sit around in a trust, like with the child actors of today. The parents—having paying jobs, since that's what's required to be a parent now, and culture doesn't change that quickly—would be using their own money to support their child's upbringing (for status competition, if nothing else.) It's only families that would currently be on welfare—and thus be auditable by that branch of government anyway—that would be spending their children's money to take care of those children. The effect of such a law would just be to take the auditors from the welfare and disability departments (which no longer exist under UBI) and move them to just making sure people aren't spending the money of people they have power-of-attorney over on themselves. ETA: this logic all already exists in cases where children e.g. receive an inheritance from their grandparents. The parents are put "in charge" of the child's money, and are expected to only spend it on things the child would—if they were an adult—have decided to spend it on (like food to prevent going hungry, or schooling, etc.), and to otherwise leave the money alone. But this isn't enforced in any way, so this kind of inheritance is currently pretty much always squandered by parents.
- CydeWeys 11y agoI haven't heard any proposals that would give UBI to children. I personally don't think it's a good idea. Have UBI start when someone turns 18, otherwise maybe you give the parents more for each dependent that they have.
- Mz 11y agoI fundamentally disagree with you. I have written several blog posts explaining why I am against basic income. I agree we need some "universal" incentives. I disagree that giving every last person on the planet (or in a country) a check should be done. In fact, let's talk about that: on the planet versus in a country. If we do not make it planet wide, it is not actually "universal income." If we make it planet wide, how do we peg it? $500/month is nothing in San Francisco. In some countries, many people live on about a dollar a day for the entire year. Further, if we do it country by country, then we create all new problems for the immigration process. If you are American and you want a check for existing, my understanding is that Alaska gives its citizens a check for existing (or used to) due to money from the Alaska oil pipeline. In part because I am homeless, I gave contemplated moving there in order to get paid to exist. I have chosen to not do so and I strongly suspect the existence of the "tax rebate" in Alaska is not some highly guarded secret, yet you do not see Alaska being flooded with inbound migrants from other states. Why is that? Perhaps being cut a check for existing is insufficient incentive for most people to leave family, friends, familiar territory, etc to go live in the relatively harsh conditions in Alaska. Perhaps a check alone is not as valuable as people who are pro uno think it is. No matter how you frame this, there are inherent problems in giving everyone a check. It is a simple idea. It is not a simple thing to effectively implement. Further, it is not an elegant solution. Elegant solutions are simple. Simple solutions are not automatically elegant. But, I don't really have more time to argue this. You are not going to change my mind. I am unlikely to change yours. If you persist in being wrong on the internet, I shall have to simply let it stand as I have other things to do. Adieu.
- CydeWeys 11y agoIt depends on how much extra (if any) the UBI in question gives for having dependents. The simplest thing to solve the problem (way more than finagling UBI rules) is just doing the opposite of what the Republicans are currently doing re: sex education, defunding of Planned Parenthood, and restrictions on abortion and birth control.
- Mz 11y agoI am fundamentally opposed to a UBI. The question of how to solve the issue of paying women with children is just one detail that I believe is problematic. But I think it is fundamentally broken through and through and I hope to god, the devil and all points in between that we do not get one.