3 ms·
The premise of the article is interesting though a little bit of a stretch. Personally I've had some exposure to AML/KYC training for Kraken's implementation (~
by contingencies 11y ago
The premise of the article is interesting though a little bit of a stretch. Personally I've had some exposure to AML/KYC training for Kraken's implementation (~5% of global Bitcoin/conventional financial system exchange volume at last estimate).
AML and KYC operate under a simple premise: if you don't comply, the government in a given jurisdiction fines you heavily and/or removes your license to operate. In practice, we've seen only 'slap on the wrist' (eg. for the recent case of HSBC laundering cartel money).
The only way this works on a global basis is that the US goes around bullying different countries in to theoretically agreeing to comply, because terrorism blahblah. Enforcement in reality is weak to nonexistant: basically other than looking at SWIFT traffic and extrapolating what they believe 'should' have been reported (definitions are pretty vague in many cases), the US has no real way to check on financial institutions.
Since basically the top 5-10% of capital holders routinely minimize tax (launder money) and much of the developing world's capital is illegally exported to western banks (Africa, China, etc.) and nobody blinks an eye, the system as it stands could be said to actively encourage a fiscal divide based upon selective enforcement.
To put it simply, money under any premise of central control acts as a purveyor of political will. Personally, I have been extremely impressed at the efficacy with which the US has threatened various Bitcoin/conventional financial sysytem exchange operators in to complying, but simultaneously deeply disappointed at the resulting enhancement of status quo.
Instead of the article's premise, I would posit the question: shouldn't high barriers to financial institution licensing be the real target here? Reporting is already arbitrary and vague, and somewhat useless to the government compared to pre-existing SWIFT surveillance.