3 ms·
I think there's a real opportunity for a grand compromise between the left and right here. If a basic income/negative income tax is bundled with abolishing mos
by marcoperaza 11y ago
I think there's a real opportunity for a grand compromise between the left and right here. If a basic income/negative income tax is bundled with abolishing most or all other government handouts and retirement plans, small government minded people like myself could get behind it.
One thing I worry about is that this could cause massive inflation and a recession (stagflation) as people drop out of low-wage work in droves. What percent of society will decide to live on solely the basic income if it's high enough to pay for basic expenses? Work is virtuous and builds character. Idle hands are the devil's playthings.
And what would it do to our democracy if a huge portion of the population is living on someone else's dime and not even trying to join the workforce. Isn't it fair to call them children? What insight could they possibly have in the democratic process except to vote their own immediate monetary interests? I believe in universal suffrage, which is why this is a conundrum for me.
- chillwaves 11y ago> Work is virtuous and builds character. Idle hands are the devil's playthings. The only difference is people will get to work for themselves, not for others. Re: the overall tone, I already have two parents and do not need another.
- marcoperaza 11y agoA basic income will never and should never happen if its supporters are unwilling to face up to its challenges. Play this offense-taking politics with it and you won't convince anyone. And you'll lose the trust of any libertarians and conservatives who are already in favor of it.