4 ms·
That's not true: strongest products ever made were high-assurance closed source. There's also been strong FOSS apps. Most apps, open or closed, are insecure due
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
That's not true: strongest products ever made were high-assurance closed source. There's also been strong FOSS apps. Most apps, open or closed, are insecure due to lack of rigor or specialist skill. Key things are right development, review, and distribution.
I broke it down in the essay below:
https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/05/friday_squid_bl_424.html#c6051639 https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/05/friday_squid_...
Review and identification/possession of what was reviewed are important points. Mass publication or distribution of source hasn't proven to be a determining factor.
- zanny 11y ago> strongest products ever made were high-assurance closed source Because we never found the backdoors put in place by the developers does not mean they were not there, and without source access we have absolutely no reason to believe anyone when they say there are none.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoHigh assurance prevents that by full specs of all success and failure states, modular code, avoidance of dangerous constructs, covert channel analysis, testing of execution paths, pentesting with source, and so on. You could conceivably slip a backdoor in with extra cleverness sure. Yet, whether OSS or closed, you depend on talent of reviewers to find it for you. High-assurance closed has most labor put into that. That's why it was more secure. Aside from activities described above that were mandatory for high assurance security but optional or ignored for the rest.
- mSparks 11y agoFundamentally disagree. They all have code that can be exploited. Not least because software is "not an island" without secure hardware there is no way to prevent the software being exploited. The trick is opensource software running on locked down hardware built in house. You absolutely cannot trust any of the developers. Even Apple has said "we can't be trusted with your keys so we can't keep them". Trusting them to provide a non compromised build of the software they make is no different, that's the whole point of the court case. If it isn't open source you can't build your own secure version.