5 ms·
Is it just me, or has there been a series of articles specifically putting Vanguard in the crosshairs lately? Between this and the ridiculous attempt to blame
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
Is it just me, or has there been a series of articles specifically putting Vanguard in the crosshairs lately? Between this and the ridiculous attempt to blame Vanguard for being too efficient and charging too little in overhead, I'm starting to wonder if there's a specific campaign going on here.
Vanguard is definitely at the forefront of advocating "just put your money in an index fund and wait, don't try to time the market". There's a huge amount of money behind the alternative that will suffer if more people follow that advice. Media campaigns are, on that scale, relatively inexpensive.
- mattangriffel 11y agoYeah, but also this is nothing new. In a recent Planet Money episode (#688: Brilliant vs. Boring), they talk about how when John Bogle first introduced the index mutual fund in 1975, it got a lot of criticism (and not much adoption) with people claiming that they were "un-american" and "Bogle's folly". It's possible that there's some sort of concentrated media push going on here, but the story hasn't changed much in the last 40 years. And I would hope that if people with a lot of money were trying to smear index funds, they'd at least come up with a new angle.
- eveningcoffee 11y ago> It's possible that there's some sort of concentrated media push going on here, but the story hasn't changed much in the last 40 years. My opinion is that if there exists campaign against such investment strategies, then it is possible that this has been going on quite long time already. Like the parent postulated: media campaigns are, on that scale, relatively inexpensive.
- EvanPlaice 11y agoIt's hard to extract value from the economy via short-term pump and dump campaigns when the majority defaults to diversified index funds. Investors with heavy ingluence/ownership of media have a lot of potential to earn from manipulating market volatility.
- hkmurakami 11y agoMatt Levine has a pretty balanced perspective on the matter: http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2015-07-22/index-funds-may-work-a-little-too-well http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2015-07-22/index-funds... His opinion iirc is that at some point there will be an inflection point where there will once again be profits to be had through information discovery, and the two forces will balance out.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoThere are always profits, and losses, to be had through attempting to beat the market. The trick is whether anyone can consistently beat the market, time and time again, such that their long-term return reliably exceeds that of the market itself. For that, I'd refer to http://longbets.org/362/ http://longbets.org/362/ .
- n72 11y agoThe point is is that it becomes easier to beat the market the more people are indexing. Thus there become more people consistently beating the market. Identification of such is still an issue, but not as difficult.
- tosseraccount 11y agoHow Many Mutual Funds Routinely Rout the Market? zero. "Look more closely at those gaudy returns, however, and you may see something startling. The truth is that very few professional investors have actually managed to outperform the rising market consistently over those years. In fact, based on the updated findings and definitions of a particular study, it appears that no mutual fund managers have." http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/15/your-money/how-many-mutual-funds-routinely-rout-the-market-zero.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/15/your-money/how-many-mutual...
- hkmurakami 11y agoAt this point, Mutual Funds are the bottom of the barrel with respect to attracting talent for active management. There are plenty of examples of active funds that have consistently beat the market. ex: Since Horseman's inception in February 2001, the fund has achieved annualized returns of 14.79%, according to HSBC. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-01-06/horseman-clark-s-love-of-losers-powers-20-gain-in-hedge-fund http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-01-06/horseman-c...
- nsedlet 11y agoI agree and think the author doesn't provide a very critical look at the issue. For one, he relies heavily on the expertise of a bank which is threatened by ETFs because it makes money in part by executing trading strategies to wealthy clients - very generally speaking, the more complex/active the trading, the more money the bank makes. Not that the Goldman guy is wrong, but the author should have acknowledged this conflict. Also the idea that somehow the average person picking stocks can help make market efficient seems like a big stretch. It's really really hard to determine a fair price to pay for a stock. And anyway, there's an ENORMOUS amount of brainpower that already goes into outsmarting the rest of the market - probably more than ever - and it's that smart money that sets the price, for the most part.
- praptak 11y ago> the idea that somehow the average person picking stocks can help make market efficient The average person is supposed to pay someone to pick the stocks for them. I wonder who could promote this idea and rally against the alternatives...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- harryh 11y agoThe thing about vanguard charging too little in overhead wasn't at all ridiculous when you consider that vanguard is owned by the people that invest in its funds. It might be wrong. It was surely a little bit weird and surprising. But it was definitely not ridiculous.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoIt's still ridiculous. Yes, if Vanguard were owned by a different set of shareholders than those who buy into its funds, then there'd be an incentive to charge higher management fees. That doesn't make doing so "anticompetitive", though. It's anticompetitive to "dump" goods/services on a market at an unsustainably low cost to drive competitors out of business (and then presumably raise prices once you control the market). However, it's not anticompetitive to, by design, have a lower price than your competitors and keep it that way forever. There's absolutely nothing wrong with setting up an organization owned by its shareholders and designed to not charge excessive fees. Resenting that and attacking Vanguard for it is an underhanded tactic by those who want to make money charging fees, and thus have trouble competing with Vanguard.
- harryh 11y agoThe issue has nothing to do with anticompetitiveness. It's about tax avoidance.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoWe were talking about two different issues, then. I was referring to the persistent complaints by Vanguard's competitors that their fee structure is "unreasonably" low, often with blustering about anticompetitiveness and "dumping". Those complaints have been floating around for years, and more instances of them arose recently as everyone scrambled to throw in their two cents on the tax lawsuit. But yes, the tax charges weren't quite as "ridiculous" (in that they require more than a moment's thought to dismiss), though I still think they're completely baseless. (And also, "tax avoidance" is the perfectly legal and sensible practice of paying as little tax as possible; the allegations against Vanguard were of "tax evasion".) While the details would need careful comparison to the various laws in question (which I would hope Vanguard has done), I would argue that Vanguard's structure is similar in principle to that of a cooperative. If you have an organization owned by its members, that organization serves only its members, and that organization charges lower prices because its structure makes it reasonable to operate at cost for the benefit of its members, then that organization will pay less tax because it takes in less revenue. And that's completely reasonable. It's not reasonable to argue that the organization should charge more to its members specifically so it can pay more tax. The same reasoning should apply to Vanguard, though how it may set up such a structure would require a great deal more care and complexity at larger scale. The details of the complaint would require careful evaluation against the exact letter of the law; in particular, this isn't a comment on the separate allegation about the "contingency fund". The above is simply an argument that in principle, I don't see why this should apply to Vanguard when it doesn't apply to smaller-scale organizations operated for the sole benefit of their members.
- twoodfin 11y agoMy favorite (obliquely) anti-Vanguard argument is the "research" that goes around every few years purporting to demonstrate that a few companies "control everything": http://www.forbes.com/sites/bruceupbin/2011/10/22/the-147-companies-that-control-everything/#6ac5a6487638 http://www.forbes.com/sites/bruceupbin/2011/10/22/the-147-co...