9 ms·
Secrets of Surveillance Capitalism
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- throwaway2048 11y agoSilicon Valley engineers need to seriously ask themselves if its OK to be enabling a future like this.
- sadgit 11y agoThey're surrounded by confirmation that it is. Plus way too focused on the details.
- pdkl95 11y agoI wonder how much the "open plan" style of office conditions people to accept surveillance.
- p4wnc6 11y agoSurveillance is the primary reason for its use. It's the only way organizations would tolerate the cost-ineffectiveness of that working style. Whether people can be conditioned for it is an interesting question. Naive young extroverts probably don't have much problem with it. Introverts of all stripes probably cannot be conditioned as easily since introverts are depleted of energy by social interaction. One of my worst fears about our industry is that it will quickly become 100% open plan surveillance offices and 100% adoption of idiot time wasting Agile/Scrum/Kanban management process (which are yet another form of cost-ineffective surveillance). Before he took down his blog, Michael O. Church had a great post warning about the "macho subordination" cultures that build up in these Panopticon-like work spaces. Young workers who don't know that the company is harming them via the surveillance culture will instead adopt a race to the bottom attitude in which people compete to be seen as most loyal by showing how much privacy and human dignity they are vocally willing to give up. The state of physical working conditions in Silicon Valley is beyond deplorable, and the trend is quickly being copied even by large firms. And don't even think for a second that it's about money. Firms pay out the nose for idiotic, opulent showpiece offices, where rows of sweatshop-like engineering stations are just office eye candy, not means of production. When they are paying for fucking fountains, roof gardens, employee cafés, and on-site rock-climbing walls, you know the argument is not that open-plan saves money. They are just getting off on how much employees are happy to debase themselves to get foosball access or craft beer. It tells me a lot about the integrity of Y Combinator when I see how many YC companies have deplorable surveillance and macho subordination work spaces, but that Paul Graham himself gained much notoriety for writing essays, like his pieces "Great Hackers" or "Maker's Schedule, Manager's Schedule," which profoundly influenced me as a young programmer, that talk at length about the cost-effectiveness of providing people with protected, private, quiet space and time to get things done. Modern YC companies, when contrasted against what Graham describes for almost a decade as good places to work, are a total farce (and the rest of the start-up world follows suit).
- anotheryou 11y agoIf they don't do it, someone else will. Sometimes it might be better to be a critical mind shaping what happens, than being a bystander. What is absolutely necessary is an awareness for what is happening, ethical guidelines and probably even governmental control. What scares me most are the techy self optimizers, with every step obedient to their fitness tracker (so far from knowing what they really want) and believing that tech will get us out just in time before life on earth collapses (well, humanity on earth, nature finds its way).
- Animats 11y agoPerhaps surveillance capitalism is zero-sum. There's only so much buying power, and at least in the US, consumers are mostly spent out. In that situation, advertising just moves demand around; it does not increase it. So all this consumer data-mining and targeting may be a net lose, just a cost imposed by the market on all the companies using it.
- titzer 11y agoIt can definitely be a loss for the consumers who are being manipulated. If through advertising they are convinced to spend $100 on a doodad or device rather than $100 on something that will improve their long-term well-being, or not spending that $100 at all, they lose. Who wins? Advertisers. Search engines. Producers. All the while, each of them convincing themselves that they're doing such a great job meeting the needs of consumers. Selling people chocolate might not be evil, but a sustained multi-year billion dollar campaign to put chocolate into the consciousness of the populace and have it normalized as part of a staple diet is borderline.
- benevol 11y ago> consumer data-mining and targeting may be a net lose It is at net lose. And our current society's concept of ever-increasing growth, based on ever-increasing consumption (aka "the latest iPhone is out, you must buy that now"), is very obviously not sustainable any longer. It was sustainable during the period when our resources seemed "unlimited" to us. It is however not a lose to Google & Co. who continually gain power over governments all over the World.
- maxxxxx 11y agoJust wait until they start selling your behavioral data for background checks, health insurance and credit ratings. Suddenly you are shut out of things and you don't even know why.
- geomark 11y agoInteresting read. But the repeated notion that surveillance capitalists are only taking from the people by selling off the behavioral surplus omits that fact they they are providing services that those people want. Yes, appearing to be free is a subterfuge for many who don't understanding what they are giving away. But for many others they feel it is a fair exchange for services they really want.
- kaybe 11y agoThe article is going much farther than just targeted advertising - it talks about predicting and manipulating behaviour in general, and about power, power in the political and personal, such as the question of who we are and our values. In combination with the article I read just before, the one about statehood in no-man's land, there is also the question of sovereignty raised. If our behavior can be predicted and manipulated by supranational companies, how much is a democracy - a state - still worth? (Note that state actors could of course do the same, though hopefully there is at least a semblance of legitimization.) This is a very high price to pay, in this described world, and I don't think most are able to even start judging fairness here, or even care enough to try and see.
- vixen99 11y agoI must admit I have no idea what you're talking about. If people behave in a predictable way then that's what they do though they are free to change, one trusts. Where is the evidence for manipulation (aside from that exhibited by all entrepreneurs from the market stall holder upwards) and to what end? Google exists by selling advertising on behalf of disparate traders; customers will therefore make choices which will change according to prevailing circumstances. Meanwhile billions of people make largely un-tracked purchases ex internet. Others are tracked and so what? Amazon and ABE Books know my tastes in literature and are welcome to push suggestions my way. If there are enough of us (like me), perhaps they'll conspire with a publisher to create a literary treasure replete with right of center (UK-style) politics, small state, free market, low tax ideas of the kind I favor. Of course I'll have no option but to buy it!
- p4wnc6 11y ago
- driverdan 11y ago> Governmental control is nothing compared to what Google is up to. Governments have guns, Google does not. I'm not saying we should ignore corporate surveillance but there is a big difference.
- kaybe 11y agoI wonder, in the future, might Google (or similar) be able to make a government use those guns? If we as the sovereign of democracies can be influenced massively, I can imagine that at least in tipping-point situations. There is a lot of money in wars too, so even without state-level actors paying, motivation is not unthinkable.
- nickik 11y agoThe problem with corporation controlling the state is a old one and Google is not particularly scary in that regard. The point still stands, if you can create a state that does not have waste powers in the first place, then neither the state by itself, nor a cooperation can use that power.
- clouddrover 11y agoForce is only one form of influence. As recently posted on HN, search engines have a strong influence over their users' thinking and decision making. Article: https://aeon.co/essays/how-the-internet-flips-elections-and-alters-our-thoughts https://aeon.co/essays/how-the-internet-flips-elections-and-... HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11255633 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11255633
- themartorana 11y agoForce is the ultimate form of influence against which there is only force to stand against it. I can stop using Google products tomorrow without the need for a gun or explanation. The article is sowing some serious FUD. Everything is engaged in behavior modification. That's the basic point of products and services. Watch more/better/less/no TV. Exercise more. Eat healthier. Stand up at work. Reward yourself with a candy bar/bottle of wine/vacation. I don't know. I'm not sold on fearing Google. The government I do fear.
- tzakrajs 11y ago"You’re giving them information; they sell your information." This is a common misconception about Google, so one can understand why the authors came to this conclusion. It would be very interesting to see evidence to the contrary. https://privacy.google.com/about-ads.html https://privacy.google.com/about-ads.html
- ryanobjc 11y agoNot sure why you were downvoted, but Google is hardly the most creepy actor here. My top votes are for Facebook and ad retargeting. One of the things people don't realize is how strict data hygene and log access inside Google is. Cross correlating data across major services in an attempt to demask individuals is a huge no-no and gets you fired. Plus there is a ton of engineers and staff who deeply care about privacy. You don't push SSL to every endpoint if you don't care about privacy.
- jacquesm 11y ago> You don't push SSL to every endpoint if you don't care about privacy. Unless you own all the endpoints, then it's just about keeping others out and maintaining your competitive advantage.
- anexprogrammer 11y agoYou do know one of the largest ad retargeters is google adwords, right? And of course DoubleClick, also part of google. https://support.google.com/adwords/answer/2453998?hl=en https://support.google.com/adwords/answer/2453998?hl=en https://searchenginewatch.com/sew/how-to/2356033/remarketing-across-ad-exchanges-with-doubleclick-search https://searchenginewatch.com/sew/how-to/2356033/remarketing...
- state_less 11y ago<Large tech company> knows Everything about you and the threat of having all that information looming over peoples head ought to cause fear. If the data is leaked and mined, lives are harmed and sometimes irreparably. Clearly there is evidence of damages and I think a lawsuit makes sense. If you poison the air with mercury causing a significant chance of fetal brain damage, you get sued. Why should you not be sued if you leak information that leads to suicide, divorce, etc...?
- ap22213 11y agoGoogle has a lot of data on a lot of people, and as such, often they're the obvious single target. But, it's useful to keep in mind that the aggregation of all data on a person, across all sources, is several orders of magnitude greater than what Google has. And, very recently, that larger set has been merged together.
- benevol 11y agoAt the end of the day, mass surveillance and the resulting manipulation of each and everyone of us kills our democracies.
- vaadu 11y agoAny writer that says something similar to Google or Apple are "the world’s most highly valued company" should be ignored. If they are going to twist the truth on this what ever else they say is unreliable. There is no publicly traded company that is even close to the value of some non-publicly traded companies, ie Saudi Aramco.
- tzakrajs 11y agoThat is like saying that the US Federal Reserve is a more valuable non-publicly traded company. The writer is implying that there is no public market to value that business. While Saudi Arabia mulls over bringing ~20% of Saudi Aramco public, this is still a far cry from the business having a proper market valuation on par with the likes of Apple or Google.
- dbpokorny 11y ago> Capitalism has been hijacked by a lucrative surveillance project that subverts the “normal” evolutionary mechanisms associated with its historical success and corrupts the unity of supply and demand that has for centuries, however imperfectly, tethered capitalism to the genuine needs of its populations and societies, thus enabling the fruitful expansion of market democracy. > genuine needs Capitalism reflects genuine greed, not genuine need.