7 ms·
This is reminding me more and more of the central theme of the book Echopraxia, which was that when dealing with superhuman intelligences, you are by definition
by taneq 11y ago
This is reminding me more and more of the central theme of the book Echopraxia, which was that when dealing with superhuman intelligences, you are by definition not smart enough to even know whether you're winning.
- studentrob 11y agoHmm maybe but aren't humans capable of learning too? One could make the same statement of two humans of different ranks playing each other. In some cases, the more highly ranked player might be the only one who knows who's winning. This doesn't mean that the lesser ranked player can't improve over time. It just means that at that moment, that player is inexperienced or less skilled, which we already knew.
- Radim 11y agoAlas, time is not on meat's side in this one.
- studentrob 11y agoI'll grant that for this very constrained problem ;-) I respect your work a lot. I've studied and used ML myself, including gensim, in industry. I've given nowhere near your level of contribution to society / the field. My opinion is true AI is quite a ways off. I haven't read anything from a ML researcher that says it isn't. Perhaps you weren't saying true AI is nearer.
- quanticle 11y agoI find it funny that whenever there's a case of computers being able to do something that they couldn't before, whether it's drive or beat humans at Go, the goalpost on what is "true AI" shifts to be something that computers can't do yet. So let me ask you this. What would you consider to be "true AI"? At what point are you willing to say, "Okay, that's it, computers are just plain smarter than we are?" Because, frankly, it seems to me that that day is getting closer and closer. Saying that AIs can't be smarter than humans because they don't think and act like humans is like saying that airplanes don't "truly" fly because they don't flap their wings.
- eddyb 11y agoAccelerando[0] starts with this quote, which I really like: "The question of whether a computer can think is no more interesting than the question of whether a submarine can swim." – Edsger W. Dijkstra [0] http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/fiction/accelerando/accelerando-intro.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/fiction/accelera... (readable online at http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/fiction/accelerando/accelerando.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/fiction/accelera...)
- hythloday 11y agoWe know that true human intelligence includes being able to help machines think better. So it seems reasonable to state that true machine intelligence includes being able to help humans think better. Other things that humans can do that machines can't yet: * change other human's minds * contribute to the state of the art of human knowledge * determine the difference between a human and a machine.
- jacquesm 11y ago> change other human's minds Computer says no > contribute to the state of the art of human knowledge Genetic algorithms have designed circuitry that we failed to even understand at first but that did work. > determine the difference between a human and a machine. For now.
- hythloday 11y agoI'm afraid I don't understand the point you're making with "computer says no". > Genetic algorithms have designed circuitry that we failed to even understand at first but that did work. This is an excellent example of what I think of as not machine intelligence. If humans can't understand it then it's something entirely different that we need a different word for - an "artefact", perhaps. Meaningfully contributing to the state of the art of human knowledge requires being built upon. If these genetic algorithms can explain how they can be incorporated into the design process by humans, that's intelligence. If they are similar to being able to evolve a mantis shrimp by fiddling with DNA, that is marvellous but not what I would regard as intelligence. We apply the same standard to human intelligence: someone who can multiply numbers very fast but not explain how they can do it is a savant; someone who can discover and teach other people a faster way of multiplication is intelligent.
- threeseed 11y agoIt could one day be possible. There are savants that have the ability to work with complex working sets e.g. reciting Pi to a ridiculous precision, multiplying very large numbers or recalling images with photographic detail. So perhaps the problem isn't our brain's hardware as such but the operating system that runs on top of it.
- dnzm 11y agoBRB, installing Linux...
- tzaman 11y agoWatch our for nvidia drivers :)
- camperman 11y agoAnd be careful of systemd. Most days you'll wake up in 2 seconds but occasionally you'll be comatose for the whole day with no way to find out what's wrong.
- supercheetah 11y agoThat's alcohold that you're thinking of.
- hueving 11y agoBut even in the savant's case, he/she can't simulate millions of games in parallel to improve strategy.
- jonknee 11y ago> There are savants that have the ability to work with complex working sets e.g. reciting Pi to a ridiculous precision, multiplying very large numbers or recalling images with photographic detail. Yes, but all computers do those things millions of times faster than even savants. And the computers are getting faster at it every year, savants today aren't any more clever than savants 100 years ago.
- jules 11y agoWhen I play chess against a computer I can see very easily that I'm not winning.
- GolDDranks 11y agoBut that is most likely be because of the structure of Chess. The evaluation of single board position is more "linear" and certainly easier than in Go. If the utility function is about winning, going though easily-evalutable board positions might be the straightforward route. If the utility function is to win while minimizing your estimate of of you losing, you might see different results. Plus if you know that you are playing against a stronger opponent, your prior might bias your perception of the board situation.
- pmoriarty 11y agoIt would be interesting to see how computers fare against humans on a 19x19 chess board, and how easily a human could evaluate such a board.
- jacquesm 11y agoThe question is not if you can see that or not. The question is if you can see that earlier than the computer can see that it is winning.
- jules 11y agoIf that is what is meant then you can't see that you're losing against any player that's any stronger than yourself by definition, because if you could see it earlier you wouldn't have made that move.
- mastazi 11y agoWhich is exactly what the parent meant
- hyperpape 11y agoAs a club level go player (4 kyu AGA) I disagree. When you play against a much stronger human, you very quickly see moves that frustrate your plans, and find yourself struggling to find moves that work. It's common for the opening to pass by without feeling behind--Go doesn't have set openings to the same extent as chess, but if you play joseki, you might have an opening where the weaker player feels ok. Even that is not guaranteed, but once you start fighting, you will quickly feel the strength difference. Of course you can play a move that looks good when you play it, but against a much stronger player, it doesn't take long for it to look bad.
- monk_e_boy 11y agoHave you read Existence by David Brin, it has a lot of great AI stuff in it.