7 ms·
What housing “filtering” can and can’t do
- nedwin 11y agoSomething I suspected was the case but hadn't heard the term - or seen any research on. In SF the battle is over what will happen in the next 5 to 10 years. In that context it is politically dangerous to support market rate "luxury" housing. On a longer timeline this is the only thing that will make a serious dent. Instead they are pushing for 25% of all developments to be affordable housing, which will retard the whole market and worsen the problem.
- cassieramen 11y agoAs long as the absolute number of units in that 75% is large enough, it can still successfully kick start this filtering process. Fascinating to see actual studies supporting what the free market is already pushing for, more luxury housing.
- nedwin 11y agoMore what I was trying to say is that we're focused on short term gains in affordable housing (the 25%) instead of maintaining our current 12% and focusing on total volume of new housing - whether it's luxury or not.
- ubernostrum 11y agoI would think the biggest concern is creating a twin bubble of tech startups and housing. Then when the tech bubble pops you get all the real-estate developers soaked by the sudden calamitous drop in the value of the housing units they put up (which assumed a steady supply of people moving in with six-figure incomes).
- dbcurtis 11y agoIn the case of the Bay Area, where are these new homes for high income buyers supposed to go? There isn't a whole lot of green field space left to develop into new, high-end, homes, so that the old homes can filter down. Silicon Valley, by-and-large, has always zoned for lots of cheap office space to keep light industrial rents cheap, in order to create jobs and reap the resulting tax revenue. But it has created an imbalance. Really, if you believe the thesis of this article, the only solution is to declare Sili Valley (and the peninsula) "full", or maybe even overflowing. Then rezone some industrial areas, bulldoze them, and build McMansions. Oh wait, industrial rents will go up and companies will move out or start elsewhere. It is hard to have it both ways.
- eru 11y agoThe solution is, of course, to build higher. Eg even the plentiful office zoning could become even more plentiful by building higher. The new homes for high income buyers could come as part of a tower where there was only a single home earlier. Density, not McMansions. Rich people, by and large, seem happy enough to live in `luxury condos' stacked on top of each other. (Or at least enough rich people are happy to stack to drive demand.)
- mjevans 11y ago//Lots// (flood the market with) of luxury condos and apartments and hotels (for long, medium, and short duration living). Extensive design validation, solid construction, not cutting corners to badly, generally actually build them to last. Plan for maintenance to happen during the building's lifetime. * Have a 'car/dog wash' area in... * A parking garage with room to actually park cars for families. * Actually acoustically isolate rooms (even within the same unit) for privacy. * Design ventilation paths that route 'waste' air away from /all/ residence windows. * If you aren't going to hard-ban smokers from occupying residence within the building, make sure that there are designated smoking areas on each floor. (A scrubbed exhaust room).
- eru 11y agoThat looks like a sketch of a decent business plan. I hope you didn't mean it as a suggestion for legislation?
- nedwin 11y agoIf we fixed zoning/planning in SF at least you could build new homes / apartments on lots that already have buildings on them. You don't need greenfield space. More relaxed zoning, including things like the density bonus, could mean turning lots that have 1, 2 or 3 residencies on them into 10++ units.
- burfog 11y agoSan Francisco owns a big chunk of the bay. They could fill it in. With proper construction, earthquake-induced ground liquification is of no concern. (build like a boat) If you really want "green field" space, of course there is that too. Golden Gate Park is huge. The Presido is huge.
- twelvechairs 11y agoThe real solution for SF of course is that anything within walking distance of shops should be built at > 20 storeys (or so). And 60% of the increase of value derived from this should be captured by government to build public transport, improve streets and parks, etc. to handle the increased density.
- ceras 11y ago>20 stories is what a lot of SF residents fear from new construction. "Manhattanization" was a big fear there. As a political compromise, consider low-rise (~5-7 story) buildings. This is what most of Paris and some of the trendiest Manhattan neighborhoods (West Village, East Village) have, and it feels nothing like what people picture when they think of densities at 80k+ people per sq. mile. I agree mid- and high-rise buildings are best for transit and commercial hubs, but low-rise in all other walkable areas is sufficient to make a huge difference in SF with less dramatic change in character, sunlight, etc--the usual NIMBY concerns.
- stale2002 11y agoWhat if they picked one small, area, perhaps somewhere in SoMA, and built all the skyscrapers there and not anywhere else? That way the buildings are all centralized and nobody gets gentrified.
- bronson 11y agoThat's already underway. http://sf.curbed.com/maps/26-high-rise-projects-changing-san-franciscos-skyline http://sf.curbed.com/maps/26-high-rise-projects-changing-san... It helps, but it's not enough units to make much of a dent in SF's housing shortage.
- ceras 11y agoSure, I agree it'd be great to pick a hub and fill it with high-rise buildings. But I'd advocate a multi-pronged approach; high-rises at hubs, low- and mid-rises elsewhere. Consider the following: (1) Skyscrapers are very expensive per livable sq. ft. and take long to build. Low-rises are comparable to single-family homes, so they're lower-risk for developers, come about faster, and have a lower minimum rent price (in the wonderful event SF builds enough housing for rents to go down). (2) If you neglect the rest of the city and create a sharp density cliff, transit patterns will be wonky. SF is in an odd in-between stage regarding public transit, and creating a transit-oriented dense central neighborhood hurts commutes from other semi-car-based neighborhoods: they should be denser to justify an increase in buses and trains needed by the city. (3) In a medium-density city like SF, low-rise apartments would make a huge difference in supply. Consider the fact that the NYC neighborhood East Village, comprised mostly of 3-6 story low-rises, is (IIRC) the 2nd densest residential neighborhood after a part of the Upper East Side, pushing over 100k per sq. mile. Because this avoids the problems of high-rises[1] (e.g. blocked sunlight, like Manhattan's FiDI), it's not nearly as unattractive to NIMBYs. The few I've met hate skyscrapers, not low-rises. I think HN might have a skewed perception of what levels of density correspond to different building heights, and what those buildings cost (in time and money). You don't really see huge swaths of residential high-rises in Manhattan most anywhere. That's due to both quality of life and cost reasons[2]. SF doesn't need to become Hong Kong anytime soon--there's not that much demand--so it's worth considering other options for the sake of political tractability. [1] http://images25.blocksy.com/L_2027825/122330054/original.jpeg http://images25.blocksy.com/L_2027825/122330054/original.jpe... [2] You could argue that in the past 10 years, Manhattan has had an increased need for more high-rises. But because of cost and the cliff reason mentioned above, it turns out a big part of the cost pressure in NYC has come from an inability to build low- and mid-rise buildings in Queens (which has comparable density to SF).
- jmspring 11y agoThe discussion on "if SF (or wherever) didn't have X, we could..." is amusing. Communities have building regulations for a reason. Despite all the towers going in in SF around SOMA/etc., you can still venture out to the pan handle, the haight, etc. and find houses and neighborhoods that aren't high rises. Here is Santa Cruz, we have progressives that tell us that we must accommodate every tom, dick, harry, and jane that wants to live here whether or not they can afford to do so. Bullshit. Companies building and hoping to scale in an area need to take the cost of living, availability of housing, and how that impacts attracting talent into consideration. They shouldn't suddenly demand that blocks of 5 story buildings be replaced with 20+ story buildings. As a bay area native, what people desiring to live in SF and what they have to pay amuses me. Yes, there is a direct impact on job growth and housing demand, but rather than insisting that a community change and build such housing, maybe the businesses wanting to grow, expand, and hire in said city should fund the development of said housing -- even if it is outside the location of the office. We already have "corporate buses", why not bring back company towns and corporate housing? Or, maybe, rather than requiring people on-site full time, think about fostering distributed teams. It's amazing how many companies refuse to even allow a modicum of "work at home" in this day and age. Any engineer is likely to get contacted by recruiters from some of the big bay area companies. Shuttle buses are better than driving solo, but you are still sitting going from point A to point B for 45-60min each way, plus your work day.
- techdragon 11y agoIn most functional urban centres there is a balance between commercial and residential tenancy which leads to a "virtuous cycle" where by the growth of one supports the growth of the other, both are allowed to grow and they both contribute to the revenue of the region though appropriate municipal/state government systems such as taxes and fees for essential services. SF got all kinds of broken by trying to have one without the other... How would increasing the burden on commercial residents help the situation in any way other than reducing demand by driving them away? Remote work is a possibility I think it's more of a long term cultural shift that is unlikely to solve the current problems without resorting to regulations enforcing remote work. Regulations which would be shifting the burden to commercial residents and relevant that would just be
- porterde 11y agoLondon just "filters" lower incomes out completely...