5 ms·
Alternative hypothesis (assuming a bug rather than intended behavior): YouTube is testing a new ad mechanism, and the new mechanism (rather naturally) wasn't te
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
Alternative hypothesis (assuming a bug rather than intended behavior): YouTube is testing a new ad mechanism, and the new mechanism (rather naturally) wasn't tested on systems blocking ads; it then produces a delay if the ad can't be downloaded, rather than silently skipping it.
But yeah, I do tend to watch most of my videos through youtube-dl these days, even though the HTML5 player works fine for me in Firefox without any ads.
- B-Con 11y ago> it then produces a delay if the ad can't be downloaded, rather than silently skipping it. I've seen at least two other popular video sites over the years that had this symptom. (Can't remember them, maybe Hulu 6+ years ago?) One of them would occasionally have a weird overlap of the end of a commercial and the video. My guess was that the video was was queued to start playing after the length of the ad by some ad-independent logic.
- Implicated 11y agoCBS has had this issue in the past as well with their player.
- spriggan3 11y ago> assuming a bug rather than intentional malice lol, no malice here, it's their websites they can do whatever they want and they are far from stupid, they test all these things. I'll still block ads and if Google prevents me from seeing Youtube content so be it. I'm not going to disable my ad blocker anyway. The fight against ads is getting interesting. Let's see who gets the "last word".
- skybrian 11y agoTesting every combination in advance isn't possible even for large corporations, because browsers in the wild vary so much, as do the computers they run on. It should show up in production monitoring, though.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoThey absolutely can; the question then becomes how much they can do so without driving some traffic to secondary sites. Right now, YouTube enjoys massive mindshare; pushing ads too hard could cause people to start remembering that other video sites exist (whether for video hosting, or competitors for the same user attention spans like Netflix and Amazon). (Also, I was using the phrase as a callback to the classic expression; I changed it to "intended behavior" to better reflect my intent.)
- peteretep 11y ago> the question then becomes how much they can do so > without driving some traffic to secondary sites Pretty far, while Adblock allows you to whitelist some sites. YouTube, boardingarea.com, and listentotaxman.com are the only sites I have whitelisted, and presumably have had forever.
- eva1984 11y agoI am pretty sure blocking Youtube ads is the lifeline for most ad-blockers...
- MikeHolman 11y agoYour fight against ads is a pretty selfish endeavor. Sure, there are some sites which abuse ads, but by visiting a website, you are getting a free service. And for YouTube, the cost is that you sometimes have to wait 3-15 seconds for an ad to play. Blocking ads on YouTube takes away from video content creators and Google.
- ghrifter 11y ago> videos through youtube-dl these days how do you find the video you want without using youtube? do you just use the youtube search interface then download the video by copying the url (w/o even clicking on the link to start the video buffer)
- stepvhen 11y agoyoutube-dl can fetch a video via its ID, the part after the "/watch?v=<ID>" in the URL. Combined with a video player, such as vlc, mpv, mpc-hc or similar, you can stream youtube videos without viewing from the youtube website. There are scripts available that make this less DIY, such as ones that launch your video player with youtube-dl when you load a page on youtube, though I do not have any of those on hand to show you.
- ihuman 11y agoYou can stream videos through VLC even if you don't download them. Just Select File->Open Network, and put in the url of the YouTube video.
- j_s 11y agoThe question was more about discovery than how the tool worked... I'd imagine he doesn't watch much YouTube but just uses youtube-dl when the videos are found on other sites.
- ghrifter 11y agoI watch a bit of YouTube, but I only use YouTube-dl to doownload videos I really like - like abridgements or YTPs - stuff that can easily be copyright notice'd down
- simondedalus 11y agoyou could search (and watch) with mps-youtube: http://www.webupd8.org/2014/02/new-command-line-youtube-player-and.html http://www.webupd8.org/2014/02/new-command-line-youtube-play... incidentally, you could also just use google.
- sorpaas 11y ago> it then produces a delay if the ad can't be downloaded That's exactly how Chinese video websites like Youku and Sohu Video work.
- wesleytodd 11y ago> it then produces a delay if the ad can't be downloaded I work for video site and wrote the player we use, and this is exactly that I think would be happening. Our player has a similar issue, and it even sometimes occurs with no ad blocker. The player I wrote loads ads via the VAST specification, which is pretty much what the entire web uses for ads. This means we have to make a client side request for an xml document, parse it, then see if it has an ad unit we can show. Even if we don't get an ad there can end up being multiple round trips due to the way VAST and the ad networks work, thus delay.
- wesleytodd 11y agoAdditionally, it might be possible that the ad blocker is silently dropping the request, which would result in a request timeout before moving on to the actual video content.
- frik 11y ago> assuming a bug rather than intended behavior ... rest of your comment So you also concluded: it's not a bug, but an intentional "feature" to suppress ad-blockers