3 ms·
I think he just needs to learn more about encryption. It's not that nerds are being absolutists. It's that the technology is absolute, and nerds understand the
by snowwrestler 11y ago
I think he just needs to learn more about encryption.
It's not that nerds are being absolutists. It's that the technology is absolute, and nerds understand the technology.
I also predict that once he is out of office he will reverse himself on this issue.
- mark_l_watson 11y agoI agree that he will reverse himself when out of office. So many people speak the truth after they get out of office - that should tell us something.
- harryh 11y agoI will bet you (or snowwrestler, or both with some share to each) $1,000 that Obama will make no statements reversing himself on this position within 5 years of him leaving office (Jan 20, 2022). To be clear his position here isn't about the value of encryption in all cases. But the specific case of whether law enforcement should be able to access the data on a phone that they have physical possession of.
- snowwrestler 11y ago> To be clear his position here isn't about the value of encryption in all cases. But the specific case of whether law enforcement should be able to access the data on a phone that they have physical possession of. These are the same thing; that's what makes encryption policy so hard. If you punch a hole in encryption for law enforcement, the hole is there for everyone. Everybody currently or formerly in a senior position at the federal level believes that law enforcement should be able to access information on a seized phone. That's not controversial. But at what cost? Shall we sacrifice the safety and security of everyone to meet this need for law enforcement? That's a harder question, and quite a few federal leaders have reversed themselves on it after leaving office (and a few in office). So, I reject your bet because it relies on a false separation between what people like the President want, and what it costs to get that.
- TillE 11y agoYes, I think it's easy to be cynical about politicians or think they're ultra smart about everything, that there's always some kind of master plan behind everything. It's much more likely that they truly do not understand the nature of encryption. They lack the expertise, and their top level advisors do as well. It's not complicated (strong encryption is super easy, regardless of laws), but they just can't accept the simple fact because it clashes with their political desires.