3 ms·
I call massive bullshit until I see it. StarCraft was one of my favorite games ever due to good design of course but also all skills required to be good at it.
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
I call massive bullshit until I see it. StarCraft was one of my favorite games ever due to good design of course but also all skills required to be good at it. There's literally so many ways to approach an AI with humans stomping them in hilarious ways basically every time.
They'd benefit best by categorizing attack strategies, counter strategies, aspects/units on map, and so on. The DeepMind system would do all that in a way that converts raw data into small, actionable information. Traditional methods could do pathfinding, buildup, time-limited decisions, micro-ing, and so on. A hybrid system seems best here.
They're not just going to throw DeepMind at it and beat good humans. We'll find its patterns, then outsmart it. Especially the pro's.
Competitions with bots and humans below:
http://webdocs.cs.ualberta.ca/~cdavid/starcraftaicomp/report2015.shtml http://webdocs.cs.ualberta.ca/~cdavid/starcraftaicomp/report...
Great survey of the problem domain and various techniques here:
http://webdocs.cs.ualberta.ca/~cdavid/pdf/starcraft_survey.pdf http://webdocs.cs.ualberta.ca/~cdavid/pdf/starcraft_survey.p...
EDIT to add:
I suggest a title change along the lines of "DeepMind will try to beat StarCraft next." That's more accurate in terms of both reality and original article.
- pixl97 11y ago>We'll find its patterns, then outsmart it. Especially the pro's And then it will learn our patterns and use them against us. AlphaGo for example, uses the patterns of millions of matches and builds on them.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoGo and Atari games aren't anywhere near as complicated as a RTS. Plus, players create new patterns on the fly. Even if it wins, then it won't have beaten us by far any more than it does with Go. I didnt have to see a million pro games to win at StarCraft or any other strategy game. I improved with thought, some tips from pro's, and limited amount of experience.
- DanBC 11y agoWhy do you think the results of competitions with toy AIs can tell you anything about DeepMind?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThey showed that a complex game with complex, adaptive opponents working in real-time with limited info doesnt work with any known technique. That means my position is the status quo until DeepMind shows otherwise by toppling amateur and pro human players without full map visibility.