3 ms·
AJAX calendar apps were themselves in that category when they came out. The conventional wisdom pre-2004 was that webapps could never replace the vast majority
by nostrademons 11y ago
AJAX calendar apps were themselves in that category when they came out. The conventional wisdom pre-2004 was that webapps could never replace the vast majority of desktop apps, because they required a hard page refresh and lots of clumsy session-management whenever the user performed an action. But a few technologies (XMLHttpRequest/IFRAMES, developed in the late 90s but not well publicized; faster computers & JS interpreters; and cross-browser JS libraries that abstracted away browser differences, developed in 2003-2006) had silently made it possible to build all your app logic in Javascript in the browser, and then just communicate with the server via a tether. This was not at all how people made websites in the early 2000s. I still remember seeing Outlook Web Access in 2001 and thinking "Wow, you can do this?"
People think of AJAX calendars as a joke startup idea now because the techniques for doing this have been well-publicized for a decade now. The trick to creating (what appears to be) a revolutionary startup is to find other techniques that are not well-publicized and then apply them in a new, surprising, and useful domain.
- Hydraulix989 11y agoThen why make the distinction? Why are certain startups considered "hard"? Certainly, the real legwork was done by the browser authors at the time who revolutionized the web by adding these features? Is it more of a call-to-action? "Make startups!"
- nostrademons 11y agoIn some ways, I don't think it is a useful distinction. I had a boss once say (tongue-in-cheek), "It's work that I don't know how to do, which makes it hard." I think that's how most people actually think about it: "hard tech" is anything I don't know how to do, while "trivial problems" are anything that I know how to solve. There are certainly some things that other people view as hard - like searching the web on every keystroke - that I view as...well, not trivial, but a simple matter of applying capital and writing code, because I know how it all works behind the scenes. I'm guessing this article is attempting to focus attention away from all of the "The fundraising environment is falling!" and "My mobile app never got traction!" posts to where there are opportunities to exploit an information monopoly, and trying to recruit founders with this specialized technical information to YC. (As a side note, I actually expect we're in for a large mobile renaissance in a year or two, with many more actually useful mobile apps becoming commonplace. But the "specialized knowledge" that will drive this is market knowledge, not technical knowledge. It's people with intimate knowledge of a problem space being able to acquire just enough technical skills (or partner with a mobile app dev) so that they can build & market a useful app. This is a power shift from technical founders to business founders in the mobile space, while the technical founders go off and build hardware/VR/AI startups.)
- Hydraulix989 11y agoGreat points, I can agree with that.
- david927 11y agoYes, and AJAX calendar apps would definitely be in that category in the 1950's also. That's not what he said. He said it's "quite the pivot from the YC of yesteryear that capitalized on things like better UX for AJAX calendars, web hosting, and drag-and-drop file storage." YC was founded in 2005; these weren't especially hard problems in 2008.
- nostrademons 11y agoYC funded their AJAX calendar app (Kiko) in 2005, before Google Calender or JQuery came out. Indeed, in the blog post where John Resig announced that he was working on JQuery, the first comment is by the founder of Kiko (who later went on to found and sell Twitch): http://ejohn.org/blog/selectors-in-javascript/ http://ejohn.org/blog/selectors-in-javascript/ DropBox was also "hard tech" when it came out in 2007; it was file storage, but it was file storage that worked by reverse engineering the operating system so it could hook into Windows Explorer, Finder, and whatever Linux file manager you were using.
- david927 11y agoNo, no, no... tricky != hard tech. I think you're arguing away from what the YC Partners would admit. They didn't fund DropBox because Drew showed up and said, "I don't know if file syncing will work but..." He was a designer who said, "I can make the user experience easier." Whether there were aspects during implementation that were tricky is not surprising but also moot. (And remember Gmail was introduced in 2004; by 2005, AJAX was not as crazy new as you're trying to make it sound.) YC doesn't fund "hard tech" because they want to make money and the fastest way to make money is to find new uses of existing tech. Now we've found we've driven that car as far as it would go and because we didn't invest in gas (new tech), we're stuck.
- Hydraulix989 11y agoWhat do you mean "reverse engineering"? Linux and Darwin/Mach are open source, and writing NT filter drivers is extremely well documented (especially for anything MSDN documentation) [1]. Either way, I doubt Dropbox even touches the OS kernel. You can implement all of Dropbox's functionality in userspace using things like Shell32 and file CRUD operations over system calls. You can't possibly tell me I need to reverse engineer my OS to write a program that downloads and uploads files to the Interwebs? Maybe inotify is the one mystical ingredient... 2007 wasn't exactly the dark ages of computing technology that you make it sound like. BitTorrent was solving the "hard problem" equivalent of Dropbox in 2001, AND it was decentralized :o https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/hardware/dn641617(v=vs.85).aspx#file_system_filter_driver_development https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/windows/hardware/dn...