6 ms·
So sad. I find the mechanics here really challenging to overcome. The hotel management no doubt wants "really cool tech" for their hotel to show they are up to
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
So sad. I find the mechanics here really challenging to overcome. The hotel management no doubt wants "really cool tech" for their hotel to show they are up to date etc. And they send out an RFQ which someone bids on, really cheaply. Knowing that by only doing the things the hotel asks for, they can throw something together quickly and cheaply for a big payday.
This is exactly the mechanism that gets people in trouble going to China for manufacturing. They say "I want you to build widgets" and they get a good price quote, and say "Wow, this is awesome!" because they have in their mind that "making things in China is cheap" but in reality its that if you cut a lot of corners you can make things really cheap, and since the contract doesn't say you can't cut corners, it is all "perfectly" legal. But the manufacturer knows what the buyer doesn't, and exploits that information asymmetry to make money at the buyer's expense without the buyer having any true recourse.
The hotel in question could have said in the RFQ, "System will be impervious to network traffic snooping and at no time will systems or a guest supplied computer be able to access the controls in another room."
Had they said that, the price quotes would have gone up and had the system the author speaks of been delivered, the Hotel could recover the costs of installing it from the vendor. But they hotel didn't even know they needed to ask for that since they no doubt would assume, "nobody would make something that shoddy would they?"
I learned about this when I saw one of the rules in a NetApp hardware contract that said "Manufacturer will install all components shown on the schematic on the final units in their designated locations." That seemed really odd. I learned that before that clause had been part of the standard contract, there had been a manufacturer who decided unilaterally that half of the noise suppression capacitors in the schematic were "unneeded." Units from that manufacturer started failing in odd ways in the lab.
- zyxley 11y ago> I learned that before that clause had been part of the standard contract, there had been a manufacturer who decided unilaterally that half of the noise suppression capacitors in the schematic were "unneeded." I don't understand how putting that in the contract is supposed to help if the manufacturer being used is pulling stupid "you didn't say the product actually had to work" semantics games that would get them smacked in any reasonable court anyway.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoWelcome to the world of law. Often I've seen it said that thinking like a software developer, looking for edge cases and such, will get you smacked down by a judge who doesn't let you just use loopholes. There is an XKCD about insurance law on this topic. But the reality is that a lot of loopholes do work, and have a better chance of working if you have a really good lawyer. Part of the equation is how charismatic a lawyer is and if they can pull up records of the loop hole happening in the past (assuming you are in a court that allows past rulings to have impact). From what I've seen it is extremely arbitrary and is extremely frustrating. I was on a jury once, where one witness was told to tell only what they had heard/seen/etc. They would try to say "I heard so and so say such and such", and the other side would object. The judge would then say to tell only what you saw, heard, etc., not what other people did or said. And I'm sitting there thinking "But what that is exactly what they were trying to do!" (of course I couldn't say a single word for risk to my own safety).
- sciurus 11y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hearsay https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hearsay
- gherkin0 11y agoI'm totally speculating, but it could be that such clauses make the breach of contract case easier and cheaper to win. It could also be that such clear terms are useful in other jurisdictions where shenanigans like that wouldn't be smacked down without them.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThis is exactly right. When you disagree with a supplier you can only disagree based on the contract, and if someone could reasonably (and there is a wide latitude here for "reasonably") argue their interpretation was within the constraints of the contract than your remediation options are limited. If you read contracts a lot (and over the years I've probably read a couple of thousand and negotiated maybe 100 or so) you will begin to see clauses that are in the contract which specifically prevent what was clearly a problem before that had not been decided as being in breach, so the added clause insures that in future contracts it would be decided as being in breach. My lawyer once told me that every contract tells a story if you know how to read it. The more I've read, the more I have come to appreciate that sentiment.
- rhizome 11y agoHey, you said you just wanted a car, you didn't say anything about an engine.
- brbsix 11y agoThere are a few realms of business that seemingly necessitate such games. It's about as aggravating as can be imagined. I wish I knew a way around it. Different people? Closer aligned incentives? The cross-cultural aspects here make it especially difficult. You don't know what you don't know.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThis is what makes people with so many years of experience so valuable. NetApp had a woman who would source parts from around the world and she had done it for long enough that she knew many (if not all) of the tricks in the book. Often her conversations would start with a new supplier and her requests with explicit constraints would tell them that she knew what she was talking about and that they had better play it straight. So they started out assuming none of the tricks they might use with an inexperienced buyer would work. That experience had tremendous value to the company.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoCloser aligned incentives, yes. If you give someone money as gradually as possible they will need to make sure they can't pull a fast one and run off, they will actually need to perform.
- Jean-Philipe 11y agoI agree with you on all your points, except: > This is exactly the mechanism that gets people in trouble going to China for manufacturing. I keep hearing about the "cheap Chinese tech", even though nowadays a lot of high-quality gadgets are really Chinese. Even Apple's products are mostly from China. And it's not even for the cheap prices, it's because the entire production chain is there[1] The mistake is not going to China, it's going to China just in order to save money - or anywhere, for that matter. I get that your point is not actually about China, but saving money on the wrong things. I'd just appreciate if we could stop using "Chinese" as a synonym for "cheap". [1] http://www.heraldtribune.com/article/20120123/ARTICLE/301239999 http://www.heraldtribune.com/article/20120123/ARTICLE/301239...
- acdha 11y agoThis is a great point, and there's a close parallel with the way that people make similar comments about Indian developers and completely ignore the many highly-qualified developers who just won't work at lowest-payer wages.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- CyberDildonics 11y agoHe wasn't making a point about China, he was making a point about cutting corners.
- acdha 11y agoExactly — and so you can make the point better simply by saying “cutting corners” directly rather than confusing the issue by using a nationality to imply it.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoFair enough, however with this audience I would expect they recognize that the manufacturing contracts of China, which by their number rather than their nationality, are expressly tailored this way. It is by virtue of the Chinese success as capturing the manufacturing contracts from all other nations in the world that has helped them develop expertise and skill.
- jkire 11y agoGenuine question: Don't the other companies talk about security in their replies to the RFQ? Wouldn't that cause the original company to stop and ask the other repliers about the security they would implement (if they didn't mention security)?
- potatolicious 11y agoWell that's just it, security is talked about but the buyer (the hotel in this case) is often not in a position to actually evaluate the vendor's claims. You can put down "device should not be hackable" but without their own competent IT arm the hotel can't possibly verify the product delivers on the security promise.
- jkire 11y ago> Well that's just it, security is talked about but the buyer (the hotel in this case) is often not in a position to actually evaluate the vendor's claims. But at least the buyer becomes aware that security might be an issues, and thus take it into account when making the final decision. (Even if its just "take the lowest bidder that talks about security convincingly"). OTOH, this doesn't work for buyers that don't actually care. > You can put down "device should not be hackable" but without their own competent IT arm the hotel can't possibly verify the product delivers on the security promise. Sure, but if the vendor puts this in the contract and the hotel does get hacked, isn't the vendor then suddenly liable?
- peteretep 11y agoWe still use locks on doors, even though they provide security theatre only. Not everything needs to be that secure. Criminal nuisance laws are probably enough to deter anyone actually turning on all lights at 3am.
- acdha 11y ago> We still use locks on doors, even though they provide security theatre only This isn't really security theater — the term refers to something which gives the illusion of security and doesn't deliver, not the failure to achieve absolute security. In general, door locks are about as secure as they're portrayed: they don't prevent someone from breaking in but they considerably increase the time, skill/tool requirements, and risk of detection. The other key part is that the threat model is obvious: people understand that if e.g. you put a Grade 1 lock on the door but leave the window open, it's not a failure of the lock. > Criminal nuisance laws are probably enough to deter anyone actually turning on all lights at 3am. How are you going to find out who to charge?
- z3t4 11y agoThis is a nice hacking story. But when you have physical access and expertise you can hack anything. So I don't understand what's so sad about it. I do advocate security in depth, and they should probably have added a few more "layers" of security, like hide the cables and encrypt the network traffic. But then he could just use a screwdriver or pull the encryption key from the device, etc. But they probably judged that stopping kids from playing with it would be enough. The guy is a freaking firmware developer and security expert!
- sciurus 11y agoHe doesn't have physical access to the other rooms on the floor, yet he can (probably) control their lights.
- z3t4 11y agoSay you got inside a datacenter, or nuclear power plant, and pulled a cable from a control unit, you would probably be able to control stuff too, and probably more sensitive stuff then the room lights. As soon as you get access to stuff you are not meant to access, it gets exponentially hard to protect from privilege escalation. As a security exercise, assume a malicious hacker have physical access to your LAN. (shares, KVM, IPMI, MITM)
- mdpopescu 11y agoRe "nobody would do that": here's a quote from Destiny's Shield, one of the books in the Belisarius series: "I was just thinking of the provisions of a typical Alexandrian rental agreement. For a house or an apartment. You know, the one about—" Zeno smiled, nodding. "Yes, I know." His voice took on a sing-song cadence: " 'At the end of the term, the tenant shall return the house to the lessor free of dung.' " He laughed himself, now. "It was so embarrassing for me, the first time I rented an apartment in Constantinople. I was puzzled by the absence of that provision in the contract. When I inquired, the landlord looked at me as if I were crazy. Or a barbarian."
- leemailll 11y agoI don't understand why you use China as an example. The example you raised happens everywhere when your contract is exploitable. Pointing you finger to China does not help your case, only shows your prejudice