2 ms·
The only way to fix that is with true school choice options. That way when parents realize it's a problem they can send their kids to schools that make a point
by brightball 11y ago
The only way to fix that is with true school choice options. That way when parents realize it's a problem they can send their kids to schools that make a point to include it rather than the ones that leave it out completely.
- briandear 11y agoYes, but teacher unions and Democrats hate that. The idea of free market competition is contrary to every bone in their bodies. That could lead to actual accountability. Currently the US school system is the Lada, free markets could turn it into a Honda.
- brightball 11y agoThis is the thing that I will never understand. I know a lot of teachers, several of whom I was friends with in college. They complain about the work environment constantly and every single complaint is one that would be resolved by school choice. Every. Single. One. Yet they're all completely opposed to it. Usually the entire reason for that opposition is fears of religious schools...which doesn't make sense. If there is that much opposition to religious schools that would mean that there's plenty of parents who would choose the non-religious options so again...a system which works itself out. I have ONE friend who doesn't complain and that's because his teacher career has been at two of the best schools in the entire state.
- crpatino 11y agoIn free markets, client is always right, right? Like in... the client is 16 y.o., loaded with hormones, and more interested in the current gossip than in the skills that will change his/her life a decade from now. The client is also interested in not having his/her parents nagging about bad grades those old bookworms like to give because they hate youth and freedom... I am extremely sure that would work OK.
- brightball 11y agoThe client is the parent, not the child. Parents tend to fall all over themselves trying to get their kids into good schools which is why property prices in highly rated school districts are always higher. Your only option is to move there, which essentially is how people of lower incomes actually do get trapped where they are...they can't afford to just up and move because the school was terrible. Now, here's the thing: to end up with a highly rated school you need good teachers. Good teachers tend to gravitate towards the same factors that any other employee gravitates towards: pay rate and a good work environment. For a teacher, a good work environment usually means administrators who support them at all times - including dealing with parents. Now this is a hugely important scenario to take into account. If a teacher is pressured by parents and fired by a public school currently...where exactly are they supposed to go? In a school choice scenario, they'd have multiple different options instead of many schools from one central authority. When teachers have more options and can simply walk out the door of a bad work environment with an unsupportive admin, they'll end up getting RECRUITED by other school administrators who know better. Parents will continue beating down the door of those good schools to get in, but right now if a parent threatens a teacher, mouths off or pressures them for better grades they are doing so with no potential consequence. If you try that at a private school you know what happens? Parent gets a warning and if it happens again the child will have to find another school the next year. The admin isn't going to risk losing a great teacher to appease little Johnny's parents. This shifts the ENTIRE dynamic of the school system to one in which teachers are in control because teachers are effectively the product. Just think about what the job market looks like for programmers right now in areas with high demand. That's essentially what the market for teachers would become.
- rapala 11y agoSchool choice fixes the wrong problem. Those children who have parents smart enough to select the right school are going to be better of in any case. It is those children that are left behind in the bad schools that need the systemic improvements. That is, if every child getting a decent schooling is what you want.
- brightball 11y agoThis misses the point entirely. It theory it should be impossible for any child to be stuck at a "bad school" because if the school was bad they could simply be sent somewhere else. It's the total lack of school choice that keeps people stuck in bad schools in the first place.