3 ms·
Yes, http://shitmyreviewerssay.tumblr.com/post/138673489984/no-new-insights-no-important-question-addressed#notes http://shitmyreviewerssay.tumblr.com/post/1386
by geofft 11y ago
Yes, http://shitmyreviewerssay.tumblr.com/post/138673489984/no-new-insights-no-important-question-addressed#notes http://shitmyreviewerssay.tumblr.com/post/138673489984/no-ne... provides a source. It's non-public-access, like entirely too much of science, but I can confirm that my alma mater's subscription gives me access to an article that has the quote in question, and starts like this:
Our referees, the Editorial Board Members and ad hoc reviewers, are busy, serious individuals who give selflessly of their precious time to improve manuscripts submitted to Environmental Microbiology. But, once in a while, their humour (or admiration) gets the better of them. Here are some quotes from reviews made over the past year, just in time for the Season of Goodwill and Merriment.
• And here we go with the first 2009 comment: happy new environmental year dear editor! Regarding the manuscript: it is OK, I hope the flu is not infecting my review brain.
• WOW! You did ‘read it with interest’ in SEVEN MINUTES??!! [Ed.: this is an author contribution in response to an editorial decision (rejection) made within 7 min of submission]
[...]
• The writing style is flowery and has an air of Oscar Wilde about it.
and so forth.