True, but if you're investing the difference in index funds dividends will generally keep going up over time (somewhat in line with the capital appreciation).

True, but if you're investing the difference in index funds dividends will generally keep going up over time (somewhat in line with the capital appreciation). >> I don't entirely disagree with the reasoning, mind you, but I think that direct comparisons between renting and buying are problematic. It's a fair point but as you have to pick one or the other the only thing you can really do is crunch the numbers and account for the intangibles and then make the best decision you can.