10 ms·
I'd be much more interested in a study that compares the top 1 percentile of graduates between countries. Of course the bulk of US graduates are going to be un
by chatmasta 11y ago
I'd be much more interested in a study that compares the top 1 percentile of graduates between countries.
Of course the bulk of US graduates are going to be unskilled... that's just how the bell curve works, and the US has the resources to support lots of unskilled laborers.
It's the top of the bell curve that matters. How do the smartest engineers and scientists in the US compare to their counterparts in other countries?
Eventually we'll have a basic income so if people don't want to learn, they won't have to.
- hn9780470248775 11y ago> It's the top of the bell curve that matters. I think that this attitude has gotten us into a pretty big mess.
- chatmasta 11y agoYou can't force somebody to learn.
- supercheetah 11y agoSure, but environmental factors play a pretty big factor in how much people will want to learn.
- EvanPlaice 11y agoBut you can sure as hell discourage/demotivate them by standardizing all classes into a game of 'guess the question', all work into mechanical problem solving, and all tests into multiple-choice bubble filling. The first class where I experienced true critical thinking was 10th grade English. By a teacher who was ejected the next semester for giving the school jocks a hard time when they acted up in class. I had the luck and very good fortune to get out of public school and attend a boarding school on a fully funded scholarship. In my earlier years I went from Minnesota where they were experimenting with teaching algebra to 4th grade students who tested high on intelligence assessments, and where we were practicing basic physics in Science class in 6th grade. To Colorado, where my school didn't even teach Science and we spent most of the day screwing around and playing card games. Middle school was light on content and dominated by a culture of bullying/bullies. High school was all about 'getting into college' and bullying was replaced with popularity contests and jocks. Ironically, I took all useful classes where I learned skills that I've used a lot since. Metal Shop, Wood Shop, Graphic Arts, and Computer Programming. All of the shop, graphics, architecture classes were on the chopping block despite the school having 5 baseball teams 3 softball teams, the 3 usual football teams, a state-winning marching band, and many teams for various other sports including tennis, volleyball, soccer, basketball, etc...
- Mikeb85 11y agoWell the top 1% in the US will look decent I think. The US had, at some point, decided they wanted the school system to be unequal when they associated funding with property taxes from each region, thereby ensuring rich neighborhoods have well funded school, and poor neighborhoods poor schools. This enshines inequality into the system, so the top will have comparatively more resources. And you're far too optimistic about the basic income. It's far from a certainty, especially in the US.
- naveen99 11y agoFunding doesn't help enough by itself, and the poor school districts get supplemental funds from federal and state governments bringing their total funding on par or higher than richer school districts. I went through poor public schools and richer public schools. Resources were not very different. If anything less competition at poor schools gave me an extra edge.
- Throwaway23412 11y ago"the poor school districts get supplemental funds from federal and state governments bringing their total funding on par or higher than richer school districts" Citation needed. Just a casual web search for your claim seems to be yielding the opposite conclusion. My anecdotal experience from moving around a lot (over half a dozen public schools from kindergarten to 12th grade) also contradicts your claim. Competition at richer schools has definitely given me an extra edge. The phrase "competition at poor schools" is also oxymoronic. What competition? Competition in classmates ignoring teachers and fights constantly erupting? The gulf between poor schools and rich schools is ridiculous. Some schools offer several Advanced Placement courses, several International Baccalaureate courses, and partnerships with multiple nearby colleges for college courses. Students at poorer schools don't even know what AP and IB courses are. You don't know competition until the top 10% of your graduating class are either all going to Ivy League and prestigious colleges or all already have credit for college courses before even applying to college. And I was just talking about the insane competition from fellow students. School resources and personnel are another matter. State-of-the-art SMART Boards. Laptops. Tablets. Multiple fields for multiple sports. Paid field trips. Study abroad. A robust student exchange program. Multiple year foreign language programs in around half a dozen languages. Teachers with multiple/advanced degrees. Several guidance counselors. Multiple vice/assistant principals. Multiple coaches. I am genuinely curious what edge you think a poor school gave you.
- mc32 11y agoThe US may also have bulges at both ends of the spectrum. With lots of children of undereducated domestic and specially poor immigrants our average will suffer.